Which plug would you recommend? Plug of Lust Small or Bootie?

Splendwhore Splendwhore
Alright, so I'm looking to try my first anal plug. I've decided I want to go with silicone to start, and I want something small and relatively inexpensive. I've narrowed it down to two options. The Plug of Lust small, or the Bootie. I'm looking at factors such as which is more comfortable, which stays in better, is easy to remove, etc. Any feedback is much appreciated. Thank you!
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
Plug of Lust small
Kinky Skier , Alura Une , ghostmonkey22 , Lady Venus , Sera , P'Gell , Rainbow Boy , Avalee , just a sub , Eat-A-Peach , padmeamidala
11  (22%)
Bootie
Kayla , Jimbo Jones , TitsMcScandal , Snappy , Rossie , Rockin' , Hannah Savage , Victoria , Phallicity , Carrie Ann , Sinspiration , Envy , ScottA , XXXXXXXXXXXXX , NuMe , Jenniae09 , Pleasured n Aroused , Anally Fixated , Research , Owl Identified , aleong , lamira , ZenaidaMacroura , Kitty Kitty , Twist , MasterBlaster , Scension Earthbound , Porfiriato , dv8 , moonlitlilly , navigator-d , Drifter86 , Gunsmoke , ToyBox , potstickers , Stagger13 , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , Lady Marmelade , miamortis , geliebt
40  (78%)
Total votes: 51
Poll is closed
06/04/2010
  • Buy 1 Vibrator Get 1 FREE
  • Limited offer: Save 25% on Blush Toys
  • Annual Clearance - Save 40%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 50%
  • Better Price Sale - Save 60%
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Kayla Kayla
From my experience with the Bootie, I'd have a hard time recommending *anything* over it. Easy to insert and remove, stays in amazingly great. Only drawback is that it isn't "filling" after you've turned into an experienced anal user. But it's great for all-day wear and just downright comfy.
06/04/2010
Jimbo Jones Jimbo Jones
I voted and am posting mostly to bump your thread. I don't have any experience with the Plug of Lust small, but I do have the Bootie and it is a very good plug with one of the best bases I have ever seen in a plug. For long term wear, the Bootie is tough to beat. The Plug of Lust small has some pretty good attributes as well, but the base is going to keep it from being as good for long term wear. It might be easier to remove, though, I've never had a problem removing any of my butt plugs (if they are big, it's getting them in that is a problem).
06/04/2010
~LaUr3n~ ~LaUr3n~
I have not tried either. The plug of lust small is in the mail though!
06/04/2010
Mp4 Mp4
Both would probably make great toys.

I have a plug of lust large(which is still very small, small might be too small for you) and it's very comfortable and stays put very well.

They're both great toys, it really depends on how much you're looking to spend.
06/12/2010
Victoria Victoria
The Bootie, hands down! For comfort, ease of use, easy cleaning, size - it's just perfect. Seriously, it is the best beginner's plug.
06/15/2010
Phallicity Phallicity
I've only been experimenting with anal play for a few months. The Bootie was a great first step into that realm. It's very comfortable, the curve is nice and it's easy to wear. The silicone had a matte feel, a slight drag to it, but since it's not used for penetration this shouldn't really be an issue either way and the texture helps it stay put. I normally prefer a slick silicone for my anal toys otherwise. =p
06/15/2010
Naughty Student Naughty Student
I have neither but I just want to mention that if you are planning on using it and having vaginal penetraton at the same time, the base of the bootie can get in the way according to a few reviews.

Just another thing to think about, lol.
06/15/2010
Alura Une Alura Une
I like my Plug of Lust! I recently reviewed it. My main problem with it now is that it slips out a little. The Bootie looks like it may stay in a little better? I suspect that it might give a slightly "fuller" feeling, though it does look comfortable. Aesthetically, I don't like bases as much as rings.
07/16/2010
Splendwhore Splendwhore
Thank you everyone for your advice! By some awesome twist of fate, I wound up receiving a Lelo Bob. *Cheers* The Bootie definitely might be next on my list though. Thanks again!
07/18/2010
ghostmonkey22 ghostmonkey22
Quote:
Originally posted by Splendwhore
Alright, so I'm looking to try my first anal plug. I've decided I want to go with silicone to start, and I want something small and relatively inexpensive. I've narrowed it down to two options. The Plug of Lust small, or the Bootie. ... More
I'd go with the Plug of Lust mainly because it's small easy to warm up to with plenty of lube and you get that awesome "popping" feeling when it comes out personally i like when the misses/mistress repeatedly pops it in and out
07/18/2010
ScottA ScottA
I went with Bootie, but the Plug Of Lust would be better for active play (in and out thrusting) because of the better bump and the pull ring. The Bootie will probably stay in better because of the long neck, and the base will stay out of the way better than the P.O.L.
07/18/2010
Victoria Victoria
Quote:
Originally posted by ScottA
I went with Bootie, but the Plug Of Lust would be better for active play (in and out thrusting) because of the better bump and the pull ring. The Bootie will probably stay in better because of the long neck, and the base will stay out of the way ... More
Agreed - the Bootie definitely does not get in the way, in my experience. I love using it in conjunction with other toys or during sex.
07/19/2010
NuMe NuMe
I voted for the Bootie because I've only heard great things about it and that is the one I would choose.
07/29/2010
Kinky Skier Kinky Skier
Plug of Lust plugs look delicious, so easy to insert. But, the booty has also had great reviews.
07/31/2010
Sera Sera
Quote:
Originally posted by Splendwhore
Alright, so I'm looking to try my first anal plug. I've decided I want to go with silicone to start, and I want something small and relatively inexpensive. I've narrowed it down to two options. The Plug of Lust small, or the Bootie. ... More
Definitely the plug of lust.
08/24/2010
Anally Fixated Anally Fixated
Quote:
Originally posted by Splendwhore
Alright, so I'm looking to try my first anal plug. I've decided I want to go with silicone to start, and I want something small and relatively inexpensive. I've narrowed it down to two options. The Plug of Lust small, or the Bootie. ... More
Go with the Bootie. It has a great design and really stimulates your anus well.
09/16/2010
P'Gell P'Gell
I love my Plug of Lust small. Granted, we use it during sex play, I'm not one to just wear a butt plug around if I'm not having sex, but we've had good luck with it. It's a nice size, not too distracting, but like others have said, "pops" nicely when you pull it out, and we've had little problem with it staying in, (except for during an orgasm, but that isn't a problem for us.)

I guess reading all the reviews on each, and deciding whose use patterns is closer to yours would be the best idea.
09/26/2010
Jobthingy Jobthingy
Although i have neither, I would think the Bootie is the best of the 2. Just from the design point of view.
09/26/2010
ScottA ScottA
It looks like the Plug Of Lust could be greatly improved by making the neck a bit longer. I have the Tantus Flirt with a similar design and it doesn't stay in place - the neck is so short that there's very little for the anus to "grab" (the internal sphincters are most of the way up the body bulge during use). The Bootie has a nice long neck and shouldn't have that problem (not to mention the small body won't make you feel like you need to go.
10/09/2010
P'Gell P'Gell
Quote:
Originally posted by ScottA
It looks like the Plug Of Lust could be greatly improved by making the neck a bit longer. I have the Tantus Flirt with a similar design and it doesn't stay in place - the neck is so short that there's very little for the anus to ... More
You are right. The neck is a little short. I got back! But, I still love it.

I'll be testing a new one from Doc Johnson in the coming week, it's TPR. (or maybe TPE) I'll let you know how it is. If I don't like it, the "Love Pacifier" is going to be in my next order.
10/30/2010
Twist Twist
Bootie is for sure what you would want.
11/15/2010
Total posts: 22
Unique posters: 18