Eye shadow palette Eye shadow palette by Bella Il Fiore
Purchase details
Eye shadow palette

Eye shadow by Bella Il Fiore

Select Color:
  • Annabelle In stock
  • Peony In stock
  • Lola In stock
Our Price:$13.99

 
 
( 46 users added this item )
 
 
Product info
Promotions

Add resource

Pretty... Ordinary, Actually.

Although I wasn't overly impressed with the color choices in the "Annabelle" eye shadow palette, the colors did hold up well with the use of an eyeshadow primer. They are neither too pigmented nor too sparkly and will work well for a smokey or sultry-eye look. Truthfully though, the quality isn't much better than that you'd find at Forever21 or a Claire's Boutique, so don't spend the extra money on this unless you just have to have it.
Published: November 24, 2011
Pros:
Compact, pretty packaging.
Cons:
A tad bit expensive for the amount you get.
Rating by reviewer:
3
extremely useful review
I used to do makeup for a major department store brand and I've tried just about every brand and price range of shadows on the market. In comparison, the Bella Il Fiore line of eyeshadow palettes are just average, with comparable ones being sold for significantly less elsewhere. The colors are appropriate for a Sex Kitten look, but not so much if you just want a nice neutral everyday look. The combinations in the 3 palettes don't really seem to differ all that much, as they all concentrate around a floral theme which limits the range of colors these palettes contain (no blues, one green, one bronze then mostly various shades of pinks, plums, and purples). If you are trying to create a romantic evening "care package" for someone complete with lingerie, toys, and body products, then this might be a little something extra to to top it all off.

I received the "Annabelle" palette which contains eight, 3/4-inch diameter trays arranged in two rows of four colors each. They are packaged in a sturdy, paper/cardboard, flip-top package that has a magnetic closure and is very lightweight, measuring about 4 x 3.25 inches and 1/4 inch thick. It's a great size to throw in a makeup bag.

The shadow colors are all individually labelled and either have a sheen/frost (S) or matte (M) finish. The colors are: Periwinke (S), Lavender (S), Hyacinth (S-a burgundy), Lilac (M), Lily (frost), Daffodil (S), Autumn (bronze-S), and Bliss (gray-S). The Annabelle palette primarily has hues in the berry/plum family with just two neutrals: Autumn (a brownish bronze) and Bliss (a gray), both which could be dampened with a thin makeup brush dipped in water and used as liners. Here are some swatch pictures I took using primer (colors will appear richer) and without one. A Primer (a base) is great to have because it significantly helps to enhance the color as it "grabs" it, holding it in place, making it last longer, and creating less "fallout" (product powder) from flying around. The pigmentation of the shadows is average, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. It just means they will show up, but they won't be too intense.



There's nothing special about the ingredients and thankfully there is no fragrance to them either that I noticed. The product does contain parabens, and for the record it's made in China, but the Bella Corporation is based out of Tulsa, OK. The company has a website ,which says their products are found in "fashion-forward boutiques and fine department stores nationwide, including Stanley Korshak, Henri Bendel and the Ritz Carlton Spas". Here is the full list of the ingredients:
Experience
I applied the colors with an inexpensive $1 eye primer (E.L.F.) and surprisingly, they stayed on my eyelids all day long without fading. I have drier lids to begin with, so I usually don't have to worry about my makeup fading quickly. At the end of the day, it was very easy to remove with a liquid eye-makeup remover.
An added bonus that would have benefited this palette would have been a small pamphlet showing some "looks" on where to put which colors.
Follow-up commentary
I still feel the same about this product as I did when I reviewed it. And I haven't felt compelled to use it again, because as I said, the payoff wasn't that great and the colors seemed mismatched to me. A nice selection of everyday neutrals would have been much more useful.
This product was provided free of charge to the reviewer. This review is in compliance with the FTC guidelines.
Become a Reviewer. Get free toys. Enjoy Special Deals
About author
Reviewed by PassionQT (Eden Advanced reviewer) Spending all my "Dildough" :)
Rank
 
7.4
wrote 120 reviews
Do you like this review?
Comments
Kira (stainedclear) (verified)

Thank you for the swatches! The lavender is pretty, but I think I'll stick with my BE and MUFE.

11/24/2011
Crystal1 (verified)

AHH, thank you! I've been waiting for someone to do swatches!!

11/24/2011
tigerkate (verified)

Very helpful color pictures... especially with and without that primer!
Thanks!

11/24/2011
TheCleansing (verified)

Great pictures.

11/24/2011
Pixel (verified)

Yay! Thanks for doing swatches! I'll be passing on these eye shadows...they don't hold a candle to my beloved indie mineral makeup.

11/24/2011
Ryuson (verified)

Thanks for the review! This set is so pretty but it seems a bit overpriced for what you get!

11/25/2011
AmberM (verified)

Thanks for the review.

11/29/2011
indiglo (verified)

It was so helpful to see the swatches! Especially with and without the primer. Thanks for the thorough review. I'm still very interested in these eye shadows, though I'll probably go for a different color combo.

11/30/2011
Michele (verified)

Thank you for sharing and the swatches!

12/06/2011
BabyL0ve (verified)

Thanks for the swatches. They are extremely helpful

12/14/2011
JRabbits (verified)

Thanks for adding pics to your review! It helps a lot.

12/16/2011
Jessie<3 (verified)

great review!

12/18/2011
Firewire (verified)

Thanks for reviewing!

Jan 3, 12:18 am
Apirka (verified)

Thanks for the great review and swatch pics!

Jan 27, 12:47 am
Ganderson (verified)

very awesome review!

Feb 17, 11:17 pm
VioletMoonstone (verified)

Thank you so much for the pics! I think the top row is so pretty.

Feb 29, 3:27 am
Review It (verified)

Very helpful photos! Thanks for the review

Feb 29, 3:04 pm
Stinkytofu10 (verified)

Great review, thank you for the helpful information!

Mar 25, 4:12 pm
LuciFaery (verified)

Thanks for the review!

Apr 13, 11:44 pm
Forum
  • Are there any single shadows?
    • anyone else wish they had single shadow shades?
    • Quote: anyone else wish they had single shadow shades?
      ... my makeup obsession somehow keeps leading me to your posts... how?
    2 posts Read all
  • eye shadows
    • do these stay on well? Are they shimmery, glittery, matte, or a combo?
    • I don't know much besides what I have read. I think the review did a good job got me interested in those.
    2 posts Read all
  • Question
    • What is the closest makeup brand you would compare this item to?
    • Quote: What is the closest makeup brand you would compare this item to?
      I would say they are like 'drugstore' makeup...covergirl, wet n wild or similar brands. The type you pay $5 or less for an eyeshadow. :]
    • Just about any brand, drug store or dept store have eye shadow collections. I would go with an inexpensive brand. More colors and less cost.
    9 posts Read all
Thank you for viewing Eye shadow palette review page!