Probably the best dick I've ever used.

As a trans-man, I know a lot about prosthetic cocks, and I LOVE to use them. The Goodfella is my personal favorite. This cock is fabulous and is almost universally loved by those who like average sized dildos. It looks real (for a dildo at least) and feels pretty real (once again, for a dildo). It is small enough that you can really pound with it without worrying about hurting your partner and it is small enough to use as a beginner anal play toy. Get it, and you won't regret it.
Published:
Pros
Easy to clean
Great size for beginners
Realistic
Free hanging balls
Not painfully firm
Cons
Might be too small for some
Not good for those on a budget
Not ideal for pack and play
Rating by reviewer:
5
extremely useful review

Use

The Goodfella is a pretty standard, although wonderfully made, dildo. It is two inches in girth and fits in the average harness. I use it with the Spareparts Joque Harness and it is truly a wonderful combination. I highly recommend that you look into the Joque as well. The Goodfella is particularly popular among trans-men for its realism, but obviously anyone would love this wonderful cock. It is a softer material and I have primarily used it for vaginal sex with my partner. She loves it. It is small enough that one can really go to town without fear of hurting their partner, which is sometimes a valid concern with larger toys. It is also small enough that it could be used anally for people just getting into anal play. It may not be large enough to satisfy true size queens, but it is excellent for the beginners out there. Just make sure you use a condom with the Goodfella or boil it after use to prevent anal bacteria getting in other, unwanted places.

It has often been touted as a "pack and play" dildo, but I don't really see where this comes from. The Goodfella is somewhat soft compared to some other toys, but it is far too large to discreetly pack and I've never heard of anyone regularly doing so with success. I have, however, heard of some people attempting to pack the Goodfella and snapping it in the process. The Goodfella is my personal favorite dildo, but I wouldn't recommend it if that feature is very important to you.
  • Who / How / What
    [ ? ]
    Who might this product be best for? How is it best used? What are the best circumstances or situations for using this product?
    • Couples
    • Gender play
  • Where
    [ ? ]
    Where / what types of places can this product be used?
    • Anywhere
  • Body / part areas
    [ ? ]
    What areas on the body can this product be used / what areas does it stimulate best?
    • Anal
    • G-spot
    • P-spot

Material / Texture

The Goodfella is made out of Vixskin. For a dildo, it feels pretty realistic, and even has free-hanging balls! I've never seen that feature in another dildo, and I really like it. There is no noticeable smell, like with some other materials, and it is easily boiled in between uses. One time it even ended up in our washing machine (by accident) and it came out completely fine! It is very durable and is still going very strong after close to a year of regular use.

It is somewhat squishy near the tip of the cock and firmer near the base. Overall, it is a softer cock, especially compared to a toy like Johnny, which is very very firm. My partner likes the softness because it has more "give" whereas toys like Johnny tend to be a little painful if she isn't entirely warmed up because of their stiffness.
    • Harness compatible
    • No odor
    • Not porous at all

Design / Shape / Size

The Goodfella is a very realistic looking cock. It is on the smaller size for a dildo, but is still probably the size of the average man, most dildos just tend to be somewhat large. I really like it because it is small enough for my partner to want to use on a regular basis. I find with larger cocks that she just isn't up to using them every night (and who can blame her?). This one is small enough to not cause soreness the next day, even after a vigorous session. It might be too small for size queens or otherwise experienced toy users, but I find that it is the perfect size for my partner and I. We do sometimes like to switch things up and use the larger Johnny, but he's too large to use on a regular basis.

As mentioned earlier, the free hanging balls are very unique to the Goodfella, I've never seen that feature on another dildo. It makes for an overall very realistic dildo, which might help explain its popularity among trans-men. However, because of its realism, it's not too discreet. People will very easily be able to tell that this is in fact, a dildo.
    • Beginner
    • Partner play
    • Realistic

Performance

The Goodfella is fantastic. Let me say that again, the Goodfella is fantastic. I like to pair it with the Spareparts Joque Harness and the result is some of the best sex I've ever had. The Goodfella is made of a softer material, so it doesn't bruise my pelvic bone after hard thrusting, as some other firmer toys have done. It also doesn't hurt my partner, as, once again, some other firmer toys have.

The Goodfella's size is hotly debated. People tend to love it, or think it's too small. Personally, I love it. It won't satisfy the experienced toy users or people who otherwise love giant cocks, but for the average person who wants an average sized cock, it will exceed all expectations.

Care and Maintenance

The Goodfella is made of Vixskin, a lifelike silicone type material. It is very safe and does not contain the questionable chemicals that some cocks have. It is easy to boil between uses to sanitize. You could also put a condom over it during use to make for even quicker clean up!

I store it in the plastic box it came in, which it just so happens to barely fit in. It keeps it from getting dirty and fits nicely in my toy chest.

I have used the Goodfella with a variety of water based lubes (currently Astroglide Natural) and I have never had any problems. However, you should never use silicone based lubes on toys, because they will eat away at the toy and cause small holes, which will then make the toy impossible to effectively sterilize.
    • Easy to clean
    • Easy to store
Follow-up commentary
The Goodfella is still wonderful. I haven't had any problems with it, and it continues to perform as I'd hope. I've heard rumors of Goodfellas snapping, but mine is still in perfect shape after close to a year of regular use.
This content is the opinion of the submitting contributor and is not endorsed by EdenFantasys.com

EdenFantasys Review Program

  • Get Free Toys
  • Enjoy Special Deals
Become a Reviewer
This review was edited by
  • Fullbeauty Contributor: Fullbeauty
  • Rank:
    5.5 / 10
  • Edited reviews: 353
Comments
Subscribe to comments
  • Contributor: CRAZYSEXYONE
    not interested in this but thanks for the review
  • Contributor: Zombirella
    Great first review. Welcome to Eden. The size would be a little intimidating to me at first.
  • Contributor: Talena
    Great review. Not sure if this is for me, mainly because of the price. But I enjoyed reading your review.
  • Contributor: funforall7
    thanks for sharing!
  • Contributor: ButchAndFemme
    Thanks for your honest review. (=
  • Contributor: Sima-pusya
    Thanks for sharing!
  • Contributor: anonymous1298304
    lol at the washing machine! good to hear it doesn't bruise that's a huge plus! im thinking this might be worth saving for
  • Contributor: ashboo32
    thanks!
Forum
Discussion Posts Last Update
Would this work with the rodeoh? 6
The Goodfella and Why I love this site 18
Saving up 16
What harness would you recommend to go with the goodfella 22
Thank you for viewing Goodfella – realistic dildo review page!