Mr. Right versus Mr. Limpy

Contributor: Sam the Man Sam the Man 04/17/2012

Which do people prefer? I know some of the objective differences between the two, but I was just wondering about people's experiences with these and other packers.

Invited: All users.

Discussion Topics

1.
Contributor: Sam the Man Sam the Man
I'd like people's subjective opinions about which packer is best.
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
MasonM , Beck , True Pleasures , guro , DeliciousSurprise , Rhiulan , Thomas90 , WD40watcher , dv8 , violets , BlooJay , meezerosity , Breas , Youssii , Falsepast , potstickers , Ghost , brevado , lisasharrer , treefrog88 , Sinfully , humpday , Bignuf , Boyqueen , MistressDandelion , Charry , J5ive , eeep , epiphanyjayne , barrowdowns , ehre , SecretKinksters , SMichelle , adavies , hhh , adam71 , heather-mooney , Andrew1992 , sexxxkitten , edeneve , WhoopieDoo , amazon , RabidPizza , Alchemagician , Winifred , Ly-Ra , Genderfree , fizzygato , Kyle Hunter , Ashtonh14 , LoganAshlee. , ginnyluvspotter , padmeamidala , srexom , victorsummers , werewolf
56  (70%)
GONE! , Stinkytofu10 , maccaj , Kiwi Green , SalmiakkiVodka , sodapin , FHeemz , Clara , icelandia , edenmysexlife , mamaseatspoop , pestilence , kdlt , moose101
14  (18%)
Chirple , DreamWolf , Leopard Kittie , beccawalton , alistair , Passion plum , ghalik , jsnyder87 , needapacker , Mediumsizedman
10  (12%)
Total votes: 80
Poll is open
04/17/2012
  • Save Extra 50% On Sexobot Attachment
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Complete strap-on set for extra 15% off
  • Save 50% On Shower Nozzle With Enema Set
  • Enjoy 50% Off Selected Items
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: Chirple Chirple
I like the extra-small Mr. Limpy - I don't know if the size is a factor here.

If I was looking at those two in particular, I'd vote Mr. Right due to material, but it would be hilariously large on me, so I'd never go for it as a packer.

I've seen some off-site, and I'm very interested in the Peecock, and would love it if EF started carrying them.
04/18/2012
Contributor: MasonM MasonM
Quote:
Originally posted by Sam the Man
I'd like people's subjective opinions about which packer is best.
I would have said Mr. Limpy at first, but I got mine just last Thursday and have worn it only a few times. Already it's showing tiny cracks in the shaft that shouldn't be there.

I'm not abusing it or something, either. I wear it packed into briefs, then as soon as I get home after a day out I carefully wash it (warm water, not hot, no soap) and gently dry it (patting, not rubbing) then coat it with a thin layer of corn starch, wrap it in a towel and put it away until next use.

Because I'm a pretty active person, I think that I might need something a bit more sturdy and all reports of Mr. Right have suggested that it is.
04/18/2012
Contributor: unfulfilled unfulfilled
Quote:
Originally posted by MasonM
I would have said Mr. Limpy at first, but I got mine just last Thursday and have worn it only a few times. Already it's showing tiny cracks in the shaft that shouldn't be there.

I'm not abusing it or something, either. I wear it ... more
That's sad you're already having trouble with your product. Do you plan on returning it?
04/18/2012
Contributor: DreamWolf DreamWolf
As am not into them I chose other...
04/18/2012
Contributor: True Pleasures True Pleasures
I'd go with Mr. Right. I've had issues with Mr. Limpy leaving what looks like oil stains on things..
04/18/2012
Contributor: maccaj maccaj
I have the Mr. Limpy in extra small, small, and medium, and the Mr. Right. I love the Mr. Right for its detail, its material and its sturdiness, but it's just too large and heavy for me to pack comfortably (I'm short and small of frame, which is probably part of it). The small Mr. Limpy is the most comfortable as an STP, and the extra small is the most comfortable for me in terms of daily packing needs. The medium is comically large and is just for fun.

A cismale friend of mine who's considerably taller and broader than me held each of them up to himself for comparison, and the extra small turned out to match his factory equipment almost exactly, including the size of the balls... which I found interesting, given the ferocious "are the balls too big" arguments I've seen. (Just for the record, I'm not implying they are or aren't, cause what's comfortable varies by individual just like the size of a cis male's factory equipment does... I just found it interesting that the extra small was such a close match for this particular guy.)
04/22/2012
Contributor: Kiwi Green Kiwi Green
i like mr. limpy
04/26/2012
Contributor: alistair alistair
Mr. Right has better colors but Mr. Limpy is extremely cheaper so it depends on which one you would prefer, but personally I would rather have the Limpy because I can burn a hole in them for an stp and not worry about potentially wasting a load of money.
05/12/2012
Contributor: BlooJay BlooJay
Mr. right has a better color, if that is a factor for you.
05/13/2012
Contributor: meezerosity meezerosity
I've been wondering the same thing since I'm looking in to buying my firs packer. I think I'm going with Mr. Right due to material, more realistic, better colors, and higher quality. If its something you'll be using a lot I'd go with the better of the two.
05/13/2012
Contributor: Passion plum Passion plum
Don't care for either, but don't have any other suggestions, sorry.
05/13/2012
Contributor: Rey Rey
I'd like to know too, thinking of getting either
06/10/2012
Contributor: brevado brevado
Right seems, well... right.
06/27/2012
Contributor: lisasharrer lisasharrer
Quote:
Originally posted by Sam the Man
I'd like people's subjective opinions about which packer is best.
mr right but limpy is ok to
06/27/2012
Contributor: Sinfully Sinfully
Mr. Right is better quality.
06/27/2012
Contributor: einad einad
Quote:
Originally posted by Chirple
I like the extra-small Mr. Limpy - I don't know if the size is a factor here.

If I was looking at those two in particular, I'd vote Mr. Right due to material, but it would be hilariously large on me, so I'd never go for it as a ... more
isnt peecock super expensive though??
heh i guess we can all save up out points for it then!
06/30/2012
Contributor: Charry Charry
I was faced with the same problem myself, and I read quite a few reviews. Mr Right is better quality altogether, as Mr Limpy doesn't pass the 'squeeze' test and attracts lint, and the coloring is terrible. Actually, I'm saving up my last few points now to purchase Mr Right. So excited!
07/30/2012
Contributor: Llahsram Llahsram
Who WOULDN'T prefer Mr. Right? I mean, it's silicone and LOOK at it.
07/30/2012
Contributor: icelandia icelandia
The Mr. Right looks incredible, however it IS expensive. Try the Mr. Limpy first, and if you pack well then save up and get the Mr. Right!
08/15/2012
Contributor: SecretKinksters SecretKinksters
Mr. Right looks more realistic.
08/29/2012
Contributor: edenmysexlife edenmysexlife
everyday- Mr limpy, reason size and shape, fits into most cloths
i wear Mr Right when i want to look like i'm packing... HE IS SO BIG he really sticks out and i have trouble zipping even loose jean around him
08/31/2012
Contributor: mamaseatspoop mamaseatspoop
I just ordered my Mr Limpy on here yesterday.
09/19/2012
Contributor: adam71 adam71
mr.right
10/22/2012
Contributor: jsnyder87 jsnyder87
I have a peecock
10/23/2012
Contributor: sexxxkitten sexxxkitten
Mr. right
10/26/2012
Contributor: Vaginas Vaginas
i like my mr limpy
10/26/2012
Contributor: Andrew1992 Andrew1992
Mr Limpy is great, and the price is hard to complain about, but it does get SO sticky. I'm saving my points right now for a Mr. Right.
10/28/2012
Contributor: needapacker needapacker
Quote:
Originally posted by Sam the Man
I'd like people's subjective opinions about which packer is best.
I haven't used the mr. right, but i hope to get one soon. I currently use a reelmajik basic packer (not bought on here) and i personally think it's the best non-prosthetic packer.
11/21/2012
Contributor: TransGuy14 TransGuy14
I'm buying my first packer, and I think I'm going to start with a Mr. Limpy and see how that goes first.
11/22/2012
Contributor: Mediumsizedman Mediumsizedman
I voted other because while I have tried and currently use the Mr. Limpy, I have not tried the Mr. Right yet, though I want to. My dislikes of the Mr. Limpy are it's sticky and needs to be cornstarched daily, the cyberskin it's made of is fragile and tears/flakes easily.
12/10/2012
Contributor: Ly-Ra Ly-Ra
Mr Right looks a hell of a lot better and more durable
12/10/2012
Contributor: Soup Soup
Good info^
01/13/2013
Contributor: Kyle Hunter Kyle Hunter
gf and i r doing a Mr.Right giveaway on our blog at end of month link come check it out
01/15/2013
Contributor: Ashtonh14 Ashtonh14
Quote:
Originally posted by Sam the Man
I'd like people's subjective opinions about which packer is best.
The Mr Right is just... Right XD
01/21/2013
Contributor: LoganAshlee. LoganAshlee.
Quote:
Originally posted by Sam the Man
I'd like people's subjective opinions about which packer is best.
Just see what's right for you! Mr Limpy is cheaper which is always a win but Mr Right is better.
01/21/2013
Contributor: srexom srexom
Mr. Right
01/21/2013
Contributor: victorsummers victorsummers
Mr. Right is better quality, Mr.limpy is not a good one
01/21/2013