Which Randy would you choose?

Which Randy would you choose?

...... ...... 07/20/2010

I want to get Randy but I can't decide between the regular silicone one and the vixskin one. I do like girth, which probably is more pronounced on the regular Randy, and love the purple/blue color of that one too. But I've heard all these great things about Vixskin as well. Decisions decisions decisions! lol!

Which one would you choose and why?

Invited: All users.

Get Adobe Flash player

Discussion Topics

1.
...... ......
And why?
07/20/2010
  • Save 20% on Luxury Toys
  • Save 70%. Limited Quantity
  • Sexy Treats For Her! Gorgeous Gift Set For $60
  • Save 50% on Selected Items
  • Spoil Him! Luxury Gift Set for Men For $60
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Sir Sir
I'd choose anything Vixskin, just because it's so realistic and so magically delicious. Mm, vixskin is such a wonderful blend. I think that you'd like it, my girl loves it.
07/20/2010
Sammi Sammi
I did choose the regular one, for a couple of reasons:

The color - the purple and blue is sooo pretty And while I'm starting to get a few realistic colored ones, I'll always opt for non-realistic color if I have the choice.

The firmness - I have another vixskin toy, and while I like it, it isn't as firm as regular silicone - it seems more floppy to me - and I wanted it to be more thrustable.

At some point, I may get the vixskin one to try out, but I am happy with regular Randy for sure
07/20/2010
Blinker Blinker
I'd go for the silicone purple one, but that's just me. I don't like realistic toys; they just freak me out.
07/21/2010
kck kck
I'd for the silicone one too. That purple is to die for!
07/21/2010
...... ......
*bump*

The forum has been moving so fast that this was already on page 3. I would really love more input to help me decide between them!
07/21/2010
*Ashley* *Ashley*
The purple silicone one, mainly just for the pretty color.
I have yet to own a realistic one. No real reason why, just haven’t ventured out to it yet.. and I just absolutely adore colors
07/21/2010
*Ashley* *Ashley*
Quote:
Originally posted by ......
*bump*

The forum has been moving so fast that this was already on page 3. I would really love more input to help me decide between them!
I'm having the same peopblem with mine! lol
07/21/2010
Ciao. Ciao.
I'd say go for the purple silicone one, I'm a fan of the pretty colors too, and I really do find the ease of cleaning and hygenic aspect of silicone to be a big selling point.
07/21/2010
*Ashley* *Ashley*
My post that is kind of like yours but with voting: Which G-Spot Vibrator would you buy and why? link

(I tried to add it on to my last comment to you but I was to late, someone had already posted behind me)
07/21/2010
Jimbo Jones Jimbo Jones
I really like the feel of Vixskin, so I would probably go for that one.
07/21/2010
ScottA ScottA
I'd love to try VixSkin, but so far I haven't. That alone might make me jump for the VS model, but keep in mind that the Vixen silicone is nice and squishy anyway, so the purple one almost definitely won't be too stiff.

Boink talks about hygiene- VixSkin is 100% silicone, so they both have the hygiene/care benefits of silicone. VixSkin is soft, so you need to be a bit more careful with it, but it can be boiled and bleached the same as the regular Randy.
07/21/2010
Kayla Kayla
The purple one because it's prettier. And that's honestly the only reason.
07/21/2010
Envy Envy
I think the vixskin one because it'd be more realistic, jsut too bad there's no more green ones, I'd want the green.
07/21/2010
Airen Wolf Airen Wolf
Quote:
Originally posted by ......
And why?
LOL I like the way you put that...you wanna get Randy. Hmmmm Vixskin is lurvely and it feels so lifelike. It's a bother to care for though. Silicone is easier to care for and easier to keep sanitary so I'd probably go for that one. I also love the purple color and I'm not much into realism with my toys snce I have teenage girls. It's easier to pretend it isn't a sex toy if it doesn't look like a penis, at least in my house. So I'd probably go for the silicone one.
07/21/2010
Envy Envy
Quote:
Originally posted by Airen Wolf
LOL I like the way you put that...you wanna get Randy. Hmmmm Vixskin is lurvely and it feels so lifelike. It's a bother to care for though. Silicone is easier to care for and easier to keep sanitary so I'd probably go for that one. I also ...
Curious... how is vixskin a bother to care for? I ask because I wanna pick up a Raquel at some point.
07/21/2010
Beth D Beth D
I'd say the purple one. It looks pretty
07/22/2010
bzzingbee bzzingbee
I'm also voting for the silicone purple one...for the color alone, lol.
07/22/2010
...... ......
Thanks everyone! I think I am going to get the regular silicone one in the purple.
07/22/2010
Carrie Ann Carrie Ann
If I had it to do over again, I'd get the vixskin.

Vixen makes lots of toys in that pretty purple and I think the Randy would feel better to me if it were squishier than the silicone one I have is.
07/22/2010
...... ......
Quote:
Originally posted by Carrie Ann
If I had it to do over again, I'd get the vixskin.

Vixen makes lots of toys in that pretty purple and I think the Randy would feel better to me if it were squishier than the silicone one I have is.
I'm concerned about the loss of felt girth with the vixskin though. Unfortunately the regular silicone one is out of stock right now, so I may end up going with the vixskin after all. Or I could wait until it comes back in stock. LOL
07/22/2010
Carrie Ann Carrie Ann
Quote:
Originally posted by ......
I'm concerned about the loss of felt girth with the vixskin though. Unfortunately the regular silicone one is out of stock right now, so I may end up going with the vixskin after all. Or I could wait until it comes back in stock. LOL
I don't think you're losing that much girth with the vixskin. Truly.

I've noticed that some vixskin is squishier than others. The Raquel? WAY squishy. The Tex was moderately squishy. The Lone Star feels uber squishy but, in reality, doesn't actually get any smaller when you squish it. It still feels quite big in use, just more comfy, like it molds to your vaginal canal instead of beating it up.

I'm not sure on the Randy since I only have the one right now but I'd imagine it's a similar situation.

I mentioned it somewhere else but the silicone randy is only 1/8 larger than the Eleven in diameter but feels a lot bigger than that in use due to the fact that it's short and stout.

I dunno. Up to you, of course, but I'm thinking a dick that big is that big no matter how squishy it is. Lol.
07/22/2010
...... ......
Quote:
Originally posted by Carrie Ann
I don't think you're losing that much girth with the vixskin. Truly.

I've noticed that some vixskin is squishier than others. The Raquel? WAY squishy. The Tex was moderately squishy. The Lone Star feels uber squishy but, in ...
LOL! You got a point there.
07/22/2010
clp clp
I think I'd go for vixskin.
I am yet to try it, and while I would also like the color and feel of Silicone Randy, I have toys similar to him. I'd like the variety that vixskin Randy offers.
07/22/2010
sophie2229 sophie2229
The squishiness is amazing. But it's still gigantic and feels bigger than the large end of the eleven. ABSOLUTELY get the vixskin (this toy made me fall in love with the stuff). Not that I'm telling you what to do or anything....
07/24/2010
Yoda Yoda
I own this toy, and can confidently say: go for the vixskin. It has lots of give, it warms up quickly, and it is much more comfortable than other silicone toys that I own, despite its girth. I'm sure both are great products, but vixskin is the elite.
07/27/2010
Splendwhore Splendwhore
VixSkin. In a heartbeat! I'm in love with the soft, realistic feel of the vixskin dildos. Besides, like Carrie Ann said, vixskin dildos feel more comfy. I must admit I'm biased, however. Not only because I love VixSkin, but also because my partner is FTM Trans. Most of my phallic shaped dildos are also realistic in color. I think they're prettier that way, honestly.
07/27/2010
Sera Sera
The regular silicone one.
07/27/2010
Total posts: 28
Unique posters: 20