Haven't used these but I always go with water based lubes if that helps

I have not used any of these yet. But I have a couple of water based lubes and love them. Planning to try some of the Silicone ones.

I've used two out of the four. It's hard to compare on lube type to another. It's really going to depend on the actual use of the lube. If you're only planning on using it for anal sex, I would go with the Jack Aide Silicone lube, but if you want a lube that will work for a variety of other things, I would suggest the Uranus Water Based. My reviews for each are here and here.

i like sliquid