Change to the advance reviewer process

I see many people complaining about the whole voting in for advance reviewer status. I had an idea that may or may not have been discussed before. Rather than the current system, have a like and dislike type feature. At the end of a time period, maybe a week, you need to have something like 10% more positive votes than negative. This would even it out a lot in that you would still get points [unless the new system changed that] for voting and people would have a higher chance of deserving their advancement.