The New Intimacy

Which packy should I get?

Skip to last post
Set alerts
Updates
Forum search
Contributor: Triangles Triangles
I can't decide which packer I should buy. I just want something that can create a realistic bulge. I've heard that the Mr.Right makes it look like you have a boner, I'd prefer to not be noticed. I don't care about having sex with my packer as I already have a great cock for that. I prefer to wear boxers as well, and I'm afraid of looking like I have a boner with the Mr.Limpy x-small as it sort of sticks out. I also look for something that will last me. I am a very skinny, 110lb 5'7" tall guy if that helps.

Mr.Limpy XS product page
Mr.Right product page
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
Mr.Right
Linga , Rawhide , eroticmutt , needapacker , Kyle Hunter , anonymous1298304 , fizzygato
7  (15%)
Extra Small Mr.Limpy
Jul!a , Ansley , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , thebest , GenderSexplorations , Brosia , K101 , Twitch , emiliaa , lzbncrckhead , ily , Sir , CherryDyke , TboyTy , Maxx , -BillD , Schattenstern , TheParrishism , Interesante , PeaceToTheMiddleEast , Sam I Am , butts , pestilence , MasonJ , lukas24 , Liberalqueer , sodapin , DarthTaco , icelandia , Boyqueen , tony , Mediumsizedman , TransGuy14 , Robespierrethecat , Ly-Ra , chort , lovelylolaa , (k)InkyIvy , Thomas90 , StayceeO
40  (85%)
Total votes: 47
Poll is closed
08/11/2011
  • Treat Her! Gift Set For Women For $69.99 Only
  • Complete lovers gift set
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Long-distance pleasure set for couples
  • Save Extra 20% On Love Cushion And Toy Set!
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: Jul!a Jul!a
I just got the Mr. Limpy and Mr. Limpy extra small and the XS surprisingly doesn't stick out at all. In my harness (the Pete trunks) it creates a realistic bulge appropriate for my size. I'm about 5'2" and wear a size 4/6 or so.
08/11/2011
Contributor: Triangles Triangles
Quote:
Originally posted by Jul!a
I just got the Mr. Limpy and Mr. Limpy extra small and the XS surprisingly doesn't stick out at all. In my harness (the Pete trunks) it creates a realistic bulge appropriate for my size. I'm about 5'2" and wear a size 4/6 or so.
Do you think it would look good in a harness under boxers? Thanks.
08/11/2011
Contributor: Jul!a Jul!a
Quote:
Originally posted by Triangles
Do you think it would look good in a harness under boxers? Thanks.
I think so. I think the biggest point is going to be making sure that whatever you're wearing is going to be tight enough to make the end of it point down. It doesn't take much to make it do that though.
08/12/2011
Contributor: thebest thebest
mr. limpy definitely
08/13/2011
Contributor: GenderSexplorations GenderSexplorations
Mr Right is definitely a lot bigger than the Mr Limpy xs. So if you don't want it noticeable, go with the Limpy. No question about it. It's really squishy and stays down very easily, so it shouldn't be as much of a problem as you think it would be. Happy packing!
08/14/2011
Contributor: Brosia Brosia
My partner has gone through several different models, but always comes back to the Mr. Limpy XS. Don't worry about the boner effect; it make poke out a bit when you're just wearing boxers, but whatever pants you're wearing will be enough to pin it down.
08/15/2011
Contributor: GenderSexplorations GenderSexplorations
Quote:
Originally posted by Brosia
My partner has gone through several different models, but always comes back to the Mr. Limpy XS. Don't worry about the boner effect; it make poke out a bit when you're just wearing boxers, but whatever pants you're wearing will be enough ... more
In my experience, boxer-briefs and briefs are both tight enough to pin it down. But if going with boxers, I'd suggest jeans rather than something like khakis or slacks.
08/15/2011
Contributor: Linga Linga
Hmmm I'm having this dilemma too but I want to pick between Mr, Right and VIP Super Soft. I want the very well hung look . Out of your choices I would pick the Mr. right personally but you should go with which ever one you feel will suit your needs best.
08/19/2011
Contributor: Twitch Twitch
my ex actually used Mr. Silky [or just "silky" on here]
08/29/2011
Contributor: emiliaa emiliaa
After reading the reviews for Mr. Limpy I would say him. Think it's cute.
08/29/2011
Contributor: lzbncrckhead lzbncrckhead
i just ordered both
09/07/2011
Contributor: Rawhide Rawhide
Even though I use and love Mr. Limpy, I actually think Mr. Right might be better for you, for two reasons.

First, you prefer boxers (and I'm assuming you'll use a packing strap). Mr. Limpy works best in snug briefs (wouldn't recommend boxer briefs, since the leg openings tend to loosen up throughout the day, risking a dick falling down your leg). Yes, the weight of your pants would press Mr. Limpy down, but clothing shifts throughout the day, so you're probably going to be adjusting more than you'd like. Mr. Right is going to reliably point down.

Second, you want something that is gonna last. Mr. Limpy isn't fragile or anything, but silicone is always going to outlast elastomer. Properly taken care of, Mr. Right could outlast you.

Also- if you wear boxers I'm guessing you also wear relatively loose pants. I'm thinking looking like you have a boner isn't going to be a problem. A bulge, sure, but not a boner.
09/08/2011
Contributor: CherryDyke CherryDyke
I'm a fan of Mr. limpy
09/10/2011
Contributor: TboyTy TboyTy
I prefer Mr. Limpy. He makes a great stp, and with a little ingenuity I have made mine so that he always points down.

Mr. Right is just too big for me, I feel like the bulge is just too big. To me, it looks like I'm walking around with a semi all day. My other big issue with Mr. Right is that the position he comes in is your only option. In my tri-suit I need to be able to position myself up and the the side like every other guy does.
09/10/2011
Contributor: Maxx Maxx
As much as everyone thinks there ego is so big and wants to have a huge cock, I think Id go with the smaller one after all I have heard about it. Yes it may be small but it produces a more realist buldge compaired to the bigger ones. From what I hear.
11/14/2011
Contributor: jesseftm jesseftm
I can't find a packer that I'm happy with. My first packer was the gv sailor packer, whichever they had in the smallest size but it always felt too big. Then I got the mr. limpy extra small but I got it as an stp and I didn't like how that worked for me. I wish I'd just gotten the packer itself because it was a pretty good size but I don't like the medicine spoon sticking out. I also have the small peecock but I just can't avoid feeling self conscious with all of them. I have the pete packer trunks and commando. The trunks feel great and I like them a lot I just wish I could get over feeling like I look like I have a major boner all the time. I honestly think a big part of it comes from having to get used to having a bulge at all, though.
11/18/2011
Contributor: jesseftm jesseftm
Quote:
Originally posted by TboyTy
I prefer Mr. Limpy. He makes a great stp, and with a little ingenuity I have made mine so that he always points down.

Mr. Right is just too big for me, I feel like the bulge is just too big. To me, it looks like I'm walking around with a ... more
How were you able to make your mr limpy stp always point down?! What kind of stp is it? I need to know the secret!
11/18/2011
Contributor: Schattenstern Schattenstern
Mr. Right seems not packey enough. And it's really expensive!
03/14/2012
Contributor: Interesante Interesante
I'd say go with Mr. Limpy.
03/16/2012
Contributor: Lock Lock
Mr Limpy was totally the right choice for me. I agonized over it, but once I got it, I knew it was the better option.
03/16/2012
Contributor: lukas24 lukas24
I think even though you are pretty tall, the Mr. Limpy is probably right because even most cis guys don't have penises as large as Mr Right
03/16/2012
Contributor: icelandia icelandia
Mr Limpy is probably the best bet for first time packers.
08/15/2012
Contributor: sodapin sodapin
I got the Mr. Limpy recently and love it
08/17/2012
Contributor: Mediumsizedman Mediumsizedman
I think you should get the Mr. Limpy next size up if this is your first packer. It's perfect for beginners.
12/12/2012
Contributor: needapacker needapacker
Quote:
Originally posted by Triangles
I can't decide which packer I should buy. I just want something that can create a realistic bulge. I've heard that the Mr.Right makes it look like you have a boner, I'd prefer to not be noticed. I don't care about having sex with my ... more
Do you wear loose jeans? If you do I'd suggest the mr right. The XS mr limpy does poke out in boxers and lose jeans.

If you have the money, I'd suggest you buy both. It's really just a matter of personal preference. If you can afford the mr. right, you can get the mr. limpy on other sites for as little as 6 dollars, or you could save up some edenpoints and buy it with that.
12/12/2012
Contributor: TransGuy14 TransGuy14
I bought both. I've been using the Mr. Limpy so far, and it's been great. I'm really happy with it.
12/13/2012
Contributor: lovelylolaa lovelylolaa
Limpy
12/20/2012
Contributor: fizzygato fizzygato
Depends.

I like the way the Mr. Right feels more. Also it comes in a clear glass box casing, whereas the Limpy comes in a powdery/ kind of gross/ concerning plastic baggy. Idk, it didn't look very clean, then I wondered if it were supposed to be corn starch? If so, I don't like packing with corn starch for worry of yeast infections, sooo, I wasn't thrilled to see the bag looking like that.

Also it depends. You seem quite a bit taller than me, so maybe the Mr. Right would be more ~in proportion~ to you (if you personally measure proportion by height? although I've often heard a second stereotype against the height stereotype, and that's that ~skinny guys are more hung than ones who weigh more~). I felt like the Mr. Right was a bit big for me, but after ordering a medium Limpy I'm like, "Wooo, goodness! I don't know why I ever thought the Right was big."

I don't use the Right super often because I like wearing skinny/tight jeans and its bulge is very big for me. I'm willing to pack with the Limpy in almost anything, but I also worry its lifespan will be short. The first time I packed with it and even just ran it along the harness, it creates a tiny scratch-like line in it.

I think having both is most worth it, so you can experience both. I like having both/ being able to choose which advantages/ disadvantages I'm willing to take each time I pack.
12/29/2012