Favorite Girl Scout Cookie

The New Intimacy

Favorite Girl Scout Cookie

Skip to last post
Set alerts
Updates
Forum search
Contributor: Pandahb Pandahb
It's that time of the year when my most favorite cookies go for sale. Do you guys/girls like these cookies as much as I do? What is your favorite?

Also note, some cookies are limited to certain areas so if they seem odd, thats why. Also, I'm pretty sure this is a full list but feel free to select other if I forgot one.
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
Do-Si-Dos
Lady Venus , Annemarie , ninaspinkturtle , ToyTimeTim , firekitten , Pleasure Piratess , Pierced Blaqk Skies
7
Dulce de Leche
EndlessFrost
1
Lemon Chalet Cremes
PussyGalore , Lady Venus , Taylor , Anne Ardeur , Pleasure Piratess , littlezimmey , cobiffle , tokensgirl , DustBunny , Teacookie , Chris Corrigan , Lildrummrgurl7
12
Lemonades
sixfootsex , ninaspinkturtle , ❦Angel Of Music❦ , Lyn84 , Victoria , ellejay , Teacookie
7
Samoas
PussyGalore , Kindred , Jimbo Jones , sixfootsex , Andromeda , liilii080 , leatherlover , Crash , Vaccinium , clp , BadassFatass , girl next door , Lucidity , ~LaUr3n~ , ninaspinkturtle , Not here , LikeSunshineDust , pinkcupcakes , ToyTimeTim , Kissaki , sexyhellokitty , Eliza , That Guy , BBW Talks Toys , ❦Angel Of Music❦ , Tori Rebel , Lyn84 , VenusianThunder , firekitten , El-Jaro , Victoria , Lily Night , DeliciousSurprise , IrishLassie , Cream in the Cupcake , *Ashley* , Pleasure Piratess , seaofneptune , Danielle1220 , Joie de Cherresse , dv8 , Darling Jen , ImBadULoveIt , ss143 , tim1724 , UnknownGirl , Lithaewyn , married with children , sasweetheart89 , EndlessFrost , Diabolical Kitty , ZenaidaMacroura , Lio , tokensgirl , DustBunny , indiglo , Apirka , LAndJ , GONE! , PropertyOfPotter , alliegator , SMichelle , Catan , requiem dreams , ViVix
65
Shout Outs!
Tagalongs
darthkitt3n , Selective Sensualist , Kindred , Lady Venus , sixfootsex , Envy , Annemarie , Miss T , TitsMcScandal , Anne Ardeur , Jul!a , ninaspinkturtle , LikeSunshineDust , ToyTimeTim , Gunsmoke , Morganna , That Guy , BBW Talks Toys , Lyn84 , firekitten , El-Jaro , danellejohns , Adam02viper , harleydhm , beautifulpierced , Crystal1 , 0 , C4ss , tim1724 , EndlessFrost , Diabolical Kitty , ZenaidaMacroura , Lio , Mary-Anne-Xun , DustBunny , LAndJ , Tork48309 , Allstars316 , alliegator , Deeder
40
Thanks-A-Lot
Taylor , Lyn84 , Kayla
3
Thank U Berry Munch
ToyTimeTim , Armsjlove , mysecretcollection , Diabolical Kitty , Teacookie
5
Thin Mints
Pandahb , Gallowraven , darthkitt3n , Selective Sensualist , Kindred , sixfootsex , Andromeda , leatherlover , Envy , Vaccinium , Annemarie , idunshire , Miss T , fghjkl , Anne Ardeur , girl next door , leela , Rockin' , ninaspinkturtle , Not here , Emma (Girl With Fire) , Coralbell , Waterfall , *HisMrs* , ToyTimeTim , Mistress M. , sexyhellokitty , Morganna , jroho , BBW Talks Toys , ❦Angel Of Music❦ , Miss Morphine , Stephanie Marie , VenusianThunder , firekitten , El-Jaro , danellejohns , Victoria , xoflxokcxo , Alys , slynch , *Ashley* , Armsjlove , Danielle1220 , magicmac , Totogrl , mystepmotherisafish , 0 , SexyTabby , MaryExy , Eden C. , zracer , ellejay , Darling Jen , wetone123 , Ajax , tim1724 , UnknownGirl , Diabolical Kitty , ZenaidaMacroura , Persephone Nightmare , tokensgirl , DustBunny , indiglo , LAndJ , RonLee , Chris Corrigan , mpfm , Allstars316 , U3H , .kaycat , SydneyScreams , peachmarie , Lildrummrgurl7 , alliegator , K. Lynn , Deeder , KinkyKatieJames , Pete's Princess , wicked48
80
Trefoils
Rockin' , ninaspinkturtle , sexyhellokitty , That Guy , firekitten , MaryExy , ZenaidaMacroura , indiglo , TigerLily9
9
Daisy Go Rounds
Sugar Free Chocolate Chip Cookies
Envy , Mary-Anne-Xun
2
Cinna-spins
Queenbee35 , ❦Angel Of Music❦ , Lildrummrgurl7
3
I don't eat these cookies
kinky girlfriend , REDRUM , The Curious Couple
3
I go nuts for these cookies, I have like 10 boxes
Pandahb , Annemarie , fghjkl , BBW Talks Toys , ❦Angel Of Music❦ , Victoria , Adam02viper , mystepmotherisafish , Joie de Cherresse , EndlessFrost , Diabolical Kitty , indiglo , Kayla , Teacookie
14
Meh
Other
Jul!a , Valentinka , Jobthingy , Ajax , barrettbn2
5
Total votes: 256 (143 voters)
Poll is closed
02/13/2011
  • Save Extra 50% On Sexobot Attachment
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Save 70% On Selected Items. Limited Quantity
  • Complete strap-on set for extra 15% off
  • Save 50% On Shower Nozzle With Enema Set
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: Pandahb Pandahb
I LOVE THIN MINTS. omg I have already eaten a box in one week, I feel so bad but I can't help it! (I wish I could use my EF points to buy more!)
02/13/2011
Contributor: PussyGalore PussyGalore
Samoas are my favorite. The Lemon Creme is second and Thin Mints are third. I haven't had the others, but the cranberry and white chocolate looks good. I'll have to get a box this year.
02/13/2011
Contributor: Gallowraven Gallowraven
I go nuts for the thin mints.
02/13/2011
Contributor: darthkitt3n darthkitt3n
I love the thin mints and tag alongs. What I hate is how Walmart is now selling their store brand version of all of these cookies, so now people probably just buy the cheap knock off that barely tastes anything like these cookies. I don't care if the Girl Scout ones cost more, that money goes towards a non-profit organization rather than a greedy corporation and the cookies are awesome tasting.
02/13/2011
Contributor: Selective Sensualist Selective Sensualist
I love the Tag Alongs and also like the Thin Mints (especially chilled). I'd never heard of the Lemonades, but if they are a thin, crisp, lemon-flavored cookie, I'd probably really like those, too.

Samoas were my favorite as a kid, and I also liked the Trefoils then, too. Ironically, I hated peanut butter as a kid, but now like it (with chocolate).
02/13/2011
Contributor: Kindred Kindred
The Thin Mints are really good frozen.
02/13/2011
Contributor: Jimbo Jones Jimbo Jones
Samoas and Tagalongs for me! Although frozen Thin Mints sounds like an awesome idea...
02/13/2011
Contributor: sixfootsex sixfootsex
I've only had one Lemonade. I need more.
02/13/2011
Contributor: Andromeda Andromeda
SAMOAS! They're my favorite. I also like frozen thin mints
02/13/2011
Contributor: liilii080 liilii080
Samoas are definitely the best but if I'm going to buy those, I throw in some thin mints too!
02/13/2011
Contributor: leatherlover leatherlover
Samoas are my favorite, with thin mints in second place.
02/13/2011
Contributor: Crash Crash
I went with Samoas, but thins mints were very, very close behind.
02/13/2011
Contributor: Envy Envy
Thin mints! *drools*
02/13/2011
Contributor: Vaccinium Vaccinium
Thin Mints have always been my favorite, and they are best right out of the freezer, IMO.

I like Samoas as well, but I feel like each one is like a gazillion calories.
02/13/2011
Contributor: Annemarie Annemarie
Quote:
Originally posted by Pandahb
It's that time of the year when my most favorite cookies go for sale. Do you guys/girls like these cookies as much as I do? What is your favorite?

Also note, some cookies are limited to certain areas so if they seem odd, thats why. Also, ... more
Dad loves the Thin Mints, I go for the Do-Si-Dos or Tagalongs. Or both.

But, yeah, I go nuts. Between the two of us and the month that Girl Scout Cookies are available, we probably go through 10 boxes.
02/13/2011
Contributor: idunshire idunshire
I have never actually seen the Lemonades or Daisy Go Rounds, but they are SO ADORABLE.

I am eagerly awaiting my five boxes of Thin Mints >.> I might have a bit of a problem.
02/13/2011
Contributor: clp clp
Hehe, awesome poll. Samoas FTW! I don't eat cookies often and I never seem to find the Girl Scouts when they are on sale. Ah well, for the best.
02/13/2011
Contributor: BadassFatass BadassFatass
Samoas are amazing. I actually have a recipe to make bars that (supposedly) taste just like them, although I haven't tried it yet.
02/13/2011
Contributor: girl next door girl next door
I love the thin mints and samoas, but have not had them in a long time
02/13/2011
Contributor: ~LaUr3n~ ~LaUr3n~
You don't have my top favorite up there. They stopped selling it years ago. But you are also missing a few others.

I chose the Carmel Delights (you call them something else). I love them frozen! Where did you get those names btw? Only some of mine had the same names.
02/13/2011
Contributor: Jul!a Jul!a
Quote:
Originally posted by ~LaUr3n~
You don't have my top favorite up there. They stopped selling it years ago. But you are also missing a few others.

I chose the Carmel Delights (you call them something else). I love them frozen! Where did you get those names btw? Only ... more
I think the names have changed over the years. When I was selling them they were Carmel Delights.


My favorites are the peanut butter patties and the peanut butter sandwiches. At least that's what they were called back in the day, lol.
02/13/2011
Contributor: Rockin' Rockin'
Wow...it's been so long since I saw a list of Girl Scout cookies that I didn't even recognize over half of these types. I remember Lemon Chalet Cremes being introduced just as I was kinda leaving Girl Scouts.

I like chilled Thin Mints the best. Mmmm. I feel like I should like Tagalongs (logically, since I like chocolate and peanut butter together), but I can't remember eating them and liking them, so I left that one unchecked. I like Trefoils! I always thought they were pretty and I enjoy a good shortbread cookie.
02/13/2011
Contributor: ninaspinkturtle ninaspinkturtle
Quote:
Originally posted by Pandahb
It's that time of the year when my most favorite cookies go for sale. Do you guys/girls like these cookies as much as I do? What is your favorite?

Also note, some cookies are limited to certain areas so if they seem odd, thats why. Also, ... more
i love them all but i just picked the ones i love the most
02/13/2011
Contributor: Vaccinium Vaccinium
Quote:
Originally posted by ~LaUr3n~
You don't have my top favorite up there. They stopped selling it years ago. But you are also missing a few others.

I chose the Carmel Delights (you call them something else). I love them frozen! Where did you get those names btw? Only ... more
Caramel deLights and Samoas are the same cookie. GS cookies are made by two bakeries, and one of them calls them Caramel Delights and the other Samoas. The name of the cookie in your area is a function of which bakery supplies the cookies to the Girl Scouts in your area. Peanut Butter Patties and Tagalongs are also the same cookie, but likewise named differently based on who makes it.
02/13/2011
Contributor: Not here Not here
Samoas and Thin Mints FTW!!! Nom nom.
02/13/2011
Contributor: Waterfall Waterfall
I am obsessed with THIN MINTS! I really need to find someone who sells them, it has been too long!
02/13/2011
Contributor: potstickers potstickers
Samoas are my 100% favorite!

I'd never seen some of those other cookies. I'll have to try them next time I get some girl scout cookies!
02/13/2011
Contributor: Mistress M. Mistress M.
I LOVE Thin mints!
02/14/2011
Contributor: sexyhellokitty sexyhellokitty
Hand over the cookies and nobody gets hurt! LOL jk . There cookies are so good, but bad for the diet!
02/14/2011