Oh that's nasty lol a day old coffee. I'll go with fresh as hell.

Not day old coffee, no...but if it was brewed during the night I'll still drink it in the morning.
I suppose as long as it isn't more than say 12 hours old or so I'd still consider it just fine.

I'd rather drink cold coffee brewed the night before than let it go to waste at least.

We only drink fresh brewed coffee, any old coffee that's been sitting for more than two hours gets poured into the sink.

my wife will leave it in the pot all day, I cant drink it if it is older then 2 hours.