The New Intimacy

What kind of crust do you get when you order a pizza?

Skip to last post
Set alerts
Updates
Forum search
Contributor: El-Jaro El-Jaro
I have food debates with my foodie friends and we can never decide on pizza crusts.

Which do you prefer?
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
Thin
El-Jaro , Chilipepper , Sammi , Carrie Ann , MuffysPinguLove , LicentiouslyYours , kck , LuLu Love , Snappy , Ciao. , Sir , Liz2 , jakjak , Jul!a , JEM , Maiden , Sidewinder , sumie , Avant-garde , Riccio , Airen Wolf , onehotmomma , VampKitty , Trashley , clp , Melissa221 , PussyGalore , Angel deSanguine , Coralbell , UnknownGirl , Crystal1 , Redboxbaby , darthkitt3n , LavenderSkies , NaughtyButterfly , MaryExy , emilia , ScotchIrish , Ansley , Lucky21 , wetone123 , Mihoshi4301 , klyte , Cookie Monster Mike , Allstars316 , ConnerJay , Ash1141 , LennaKieran , jeangel246 , PeaceToTheMiddleEast , ellejay , shannyshann , brevado , potstickers , table38792 , Incendiaire , Trysexual , Alyona , doowop , bayosgirl , kdlt
61
Thick
Dame Saphir , Hannah Savage , Sir , Gary , Kim! , Jul!a , JEM , Maiden , Jenniae09 , Persephone Nightmare , Riccio , JPito , Jobthingy , Lady Venus , VampKitty , Trashley , Love Buzz , Hot'n'Bothered , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , Purpleladybug , REDRUM , Xavier7 , haley730 , The Curious Couple , GONE! , NicNat , MK434 , Incendiaire , 1001 Pleasures , Lildrummrgurl7 , jr2012 , Jax Jackson , DeliciousB , "G" , Hummingbird
35
Hand tosssed
Alicia , Chilipepper , MarriedWithToyz , Passionate Pastor , SexyFox3 , softcoeur , ~LaUr3n~ , hands.red , VieuxCarre , Maxim , Gunsmoke , LuLu Love , jakjak , Jul!a , Red Vinyl Kitty , ♥ Amanda ♥ , bzzingbee , Maiden , fatesrelease , Persephone Nightmare , Airen Wolf , Illusional , ToyTimeTim , Kindred , Kimmie1980ca , Speckledorf , Lady Venus , lamira , VampKitty , Trashley , Hot'n'Bothered , Eeyor89 , 34 , gehuwd , Lio , darthkitt3n , TheSinDoll , staceejaxxx , Rainbow Boy , buzz , That Guy , Xavier7 , sarahbear , yw2 , SexyTabby , Taylor , *HisMrs* , Pandahb , Ansley , unfulfilled , Lucky21 , MrWishyWashy , wetone123 , Cookie Monster Mike , Ash1141 , Kitka , LennaKieran , NicNat , Chefbriapink , brevado , table38792 , doowop , ViVix , Lildrummrgurl7 , nikki0668 , Allison.Wilder
66
Deep Dish
Miss Cinnamon , Andromeda , Yesenia , Jimbo Jones , Hannah Savage , Annemarie , pornshopgirl , Fun Lover , Sir , jakjak , Jul!a , Maiden , Sidewinder , Selective Sensualist , Persephone Nightmare , JPito , Pleasure Piratess , Lady Venus , VampKitty , Melissa221 , PussyGalore , Angel deSanguine , That Guy , Miss T , dv8 , *HisMrs* , jroho , padmeamidala , Cherry21 , Love Perpetua , Cookie Monster Mike , MR Chickhabit , EnChAnTiNg , NicNat , FLIPxMODE , Living Doll , big b , doowop , explorer7 , Lildrummrgurl7 , DawnStar , Beautiful-Disaster , Vanille , Hummingbird
44
Frozen
Sir , Jul!a , VampKitty , BluePixi
4
Stuffed
Andromeda , VieuxCarre , Sir , jakjak , Jul!a , JEM , gone77 , bzzingbee , Maiden , Sidewinder , Jenniae09 , Lady Venus , VampKitty , Miss Naughty Kitty , clp , Lio , That Guy , LilLostLenore , Ansley , dude , meitman , Jordan B , Cherry21 , Cookie Monster Mike , Ash1141 , jeangel246 , FemmeFlo , PeaceToTheMiddleEast , FLIPxMODE , doowop , Raymaker , ViVix , DawnStar , nikki0668 , Beautiful-Disaster , butts , Vanille , kdlt
38
I CAN PICK!?!?!
ToyTimeTim , Envy , BluePixi , DustBunny , Xavier7 , MaryExy , SecondStory , Flower1
8
Pikachu!
MuffysPinguLove , kck , Sir , Persephone Nightmare , namelesschaos , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , Envy , DustBunny , buzz , Xavier7 , LilLostLenore , Mrs.Tee
12
Total votes: 268 (170 voters)
Poll is closed
06/02/2010
  • Treat Her! Gift Set For Women For $69.99 Only
  • Complete lovers gift set
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Long-distance pleasure set for couples
  • Save Extra 20% On Love Cushion And Toy Set!
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: MarriedWithToyz MarriedWithToyz
I love all kinds of pizza, but hand tossed is the ultimate! And now I'm craving New York pizza, miss it a real lot!!
06/02/2010
Contributor: Chilipepper Chilipepper
Quote:
Originally posted by MarriedWithToyz
I love all kinds of pizza, but hand tossed is the ultimate! And now I'm craving New York pizza, miss it a real lot!!
I agree about missing certain types ... Papa Murphy's Take and Bake Pizza in Hamilton, Montana ... Damn, I miss it!
06/02/2010
Contributor: Sammi Sammi
Papa Murphy's rules!

I almost never eat the crust - just the toppings. But when i do, the thinner the better.
06/02/2010
Contributor: Carrie Ann Carrie Ann
Thin crust. I am eating one right NOW. Nom nom nom
06/02/2010
Contributor: MuffysPinguLove MuffysPinguLove
Pickachu is totally my favorite kind of crust! Sadly, not all pizza places carry Pokemon themed pizza, so I usually go with thin crust instead
06/02/2010
Contributor: Miss Cinnamon Miss Cinnamon
I adore deep dish, especially Cottage Inn's deep dish Sicilian. I like Pizza Hut's pan pizza too, but nothing beats the feeling of sinking your teeth into a generous heaping of cheese and toppings. While thin crust is great and all, it's kind of like eating peanut butter on a cracker versus a bona fide peanut butter sandwich. There's just no comparison.

Guhhh. Now I'm hungry! And I only have ramen TT__TT
06/02/2010
Contributor: LicentiouslyYours LicentiouslyYours
Quote:
Originally posted by Carrie Ann
Thin crust. I am eating one right NOW. Nom nom nom
*steals Carrie Ann's pizza* Is hungry.

Gimme!
06/03/2010
Contributor: ~LaUr3n~ ~LaUr3n~
I love the new hand tossed crust. It is like garlic bread attached to the pizza! So good.
06/03/2010
Contributor: hands.red hands.red
I love hand tossed. I had pizza last night actually. It was tasty. Mmmm.
06/03/2010
Contributor: VieuxCarre VieuxCarre
Why do you do this to me, JR? You know I'm on a diet and are tormenting me, huh? Just kidding

I love hand tossed, but I'm picky about where I get my pizza from. I find that a lot of places coat their crust in sauce and it irritates my stomach.

I wish I could eat pizza more. Silly diet and lack of being able to handle too much grease
06/03/2010
Contributor: Maxim Maxim
Thin or hand tossed.
Question is where can I get the best pizza in central NJ?
06/03/2010
Contributor: LuLu Love LuLu Love
Nothing beats homemade pizza on the grill!!! mmmmmm
06/03/2010
Contributor: Carrie Ann Carrie Ann
Quote:
Originally posted by LicentiouslyYours
*steals Carrie Ann's pizza* Is hungry.

Gimme!
Hey! No wonder it vanished so fast!
06/03/2010
Contributor: Hannah Savage Hannah Savage
I love, love, love thick, bready crust. Thin crust to me is exactly like Cynthia's example--a cracker. The crunch of thin crust is great but I'd choose deep dish or thick crust over it any day.

Unfortunately, the boyfriend loves thin crust. And tabasco sauce on his pizza. I hate both. Boohoo.
06/03/2010
Contributor: El-Jaro El-Jaro
There's a downside to thin crust: Eating the whole large pizza. I've done this a few times without realizing it!
06/03/2010
Contributor: Annemarie Annemarie
Deep dish all the way.

Yeah, it's greasy, yeah, it's probably going to give me a heart attack in 5 years... but it's just so damn tasty.
06/03/2010
Contributor: Gary Gary
I like the thick Sicilian style!
06/03/2010
Contributor: Miss Cinnamon Miss Cinnamon
Quote:
Originally posted by Gary
I like the thick Sicilian style!
Woohoo! Sicilian!
06/03/2010
Contributor: pornshopgirl pornshopgirl
I'm from the Chicago suburbs, so I gotta go with deep dish. And I mean deeeeep- like, so thick you have you eat it with a knife and fork. Any Giordano's fans out there?
06/05/2010
Contributor: El-Jaro El-Jaro
Quote:
Originally posted by pornshopgirl
I'm from the Chicago suburbs, so I gotta go with deep dish. And I mean deeeeep- like, so thick you have you eat it with a knife and fork. Any Giordano's fans out there?
I've eaten at exactly ONE Chicago pizza place. I don't remember the name or the burb, except that it was where all the FLW was at.
06/05/2010
Contributor: Ciao. Ciao.
I prefer thin crust or hand-tossed. Our town is full of only Greek pizza places which only go the thin crust route which works well for me.
06/05/2010
Contributor: Liz2 Liz2
I love thin crust but not readily available here...I so miss NYC!!
06/07/2010
Contributor: Gary Gary
Quote:
Originally posted by pornshopgirl
I'm from the Chicago suburbs, so I gotta go with deep dish. And I mean deeeeep- like, so thick you have you eat it with a knife and fork. Any Giordano's fans out there?
That sounds awesome!
06/10/2010
Contributor: Miss Cinnamon Miss Cinnamon
Quote:
Originally posted by pornshopgirl
I'm from the Chicago suburbs, so I gotta go with deep dish. And I mean deeeeep- like, so thick you have you eat it with a knife and fork. Any Giordano's fans out there?
I had to look up Giordano because it's also popular Hong Kong clothing brand So I found pics of the Giordano pizza and it looks AMAZING! That's precisely what I like my pizza to be--as thick and full of yum as possible.
06/10/2010
Contributor: VieuxCarre VieuxCarre
I had pizza the other night. It was so delicious. And I thought of this thread when I ordered it. I almost told the delivery guy "I choose you, Pizzachu!" but I think he'd have looked at me funny and told my boss to fire me...
06/11/2010
Contributor: Miss Cinnamon Miss Cinnamon
Quote:
Originally posted by VieuxCarre
I had pizza the other night. It was so delicious. And I thought of this thread when I ordered it. I almost told the delivery guy "I choose you, Pizzachu!" but I think he'd have looked at me funny and told my boss to fire me...
Too funny! I've said random things to employees in Home Depot before, but never to pizza guys.

I'm really craving pizza now
06/21/2010
Contributor: Sammi Sammi
Quote:
Originally posted by VieuxCarre
I had pizza the other night. It was so delicious. And I thought of this thread when I ordered it. I almost told the delivery guy "I choose you, Pizzachu!" but I think he'd have looked at me funny and told my boss to fire me...
LMAO - now I want to say that to our delivery guy
06/21/2010
Contributor: gone77 gone77
The fam and I tend to prefer our crust to be stuffed, but since it's usually a $1 or $2 extra, we often get hand-tossed. Deep dish tends to be too greasy for my liking. I do like thin crust on occasion. Damn, now I'm wanting pizza with stuffed crust. Yummy.
06/21/2010
Contributor: bzzingbee bzzingbee
I'm also now craving pizza, lol
06/21/2010