I kept everything. As the way I see it, since I was WAY more interested in the stuff than she was, I'm entitled to it. Not a heck of a lot of sentimental value in the toys since they were all basically mine and solo-used anyway. But I can see some people having a hard time keeping them.

Quite honestly, there was only two or three toys that I had with my ex and with my current fiance. None of them really got used with my ex that much, and neither my fiance or myself had a problem with using them together. If he had wanted me to buy a replacement of one or two of them so we could still use it, just not the one that got used with somebody else, I would have.

The only toy I had before finding my current guy broke way before we met. Luckily I discovered Eden during our relationship, so lucky for him I am stocked with some sex toys. If things ever end, I wouldn't throw away my toys, mostly because I'm incredibly materialistic. Seriously. I'm a borderline hoarder. I love all my toys and plan on keeping them for as long as I can. I get more use out of his cock when we're together instead of my toys.

Well, I've never been in this situation really because all the toys I've used with a partner have been with my husband. But, I can see getting rid of toys such as cock rings, or other partner toys.

I think I only have one toy that is really sentimental. I have it, not him. I probably won't use it again but it is a bdsm toy which holds a bit more meaning for me.

I get new ones for each partner.

Kept everything, how is it any different than the real deal

Nothing I own reminds me of past partners, probably because I usually don't use toys in the bedroom (aside from alone!) or if I do it's not a personal "me and that particular person" thing. Haha. ^_^