Due to the relatively high number of fake/unreadable reviews currently in the task list, I have been adding a comment in the title line. However this is being deleted by unscrupulous writers to get their junk published. To this end I have been adding a comment at the bottom, where it cannot be deleted. I also find that other editors who are working with authors will put a note at the bottom. So to avoid re-editing, or worse, publishing stolen junk, I am now always checking the bottom of the review for editor comments. The task market continues to be plagued with new plagiarists and some really unreadable writing.
MOST of the legitimate reviews are very well written (I can't speak to content), and don't need a lot of editing. I always try to leave their authors a positive note.
MOST of the legitimate reviews are very well written (I can't speak to content), and don't need a lot of editing. I always try to leave their authors a positive note.
