bacon!
No Experience Required Vs. Experience Necessary
05/24/2012
it's helpful. & bacon.
05/29/2012
Quote:
I do like when people talk about their experience
Originally posted by
Ms. N
Since I have been on the editing rotation this time, I have been noticing that the vast majority of Standard Reviews have no experience listed. Now, I realize that the section says that experience is optional, but should it be? Do you prefer to
...
more
Since I have been on the editing rotation this time, I have been noticing that the vast majority of Standard Reviews have no experience listed. Now, I realize that the section says that experience is optional, but should it be? Do you prefer to read reviews that include experience? Do you rate a review lower if there is no experience included?
less
06/06/2012
Experience is often relevant in other sections of the review; for example, if I experienced an issue with the material in use, I write about that in the material section. The experience section isn't strictly necessary as long as it's covered elsewhere.
06/22/2012
Quote:
Sometimes I mix experience up with performance together. I like to talk about performance then followed by how it effected me personally. I don't think any section should be required. Maybe that one descriptive review should cover everything. As for other reviews, people should have a lot of freedom.
Originally posted by
Ms. N
Since I have been on the editing rotation this time, I have been noticing that the vast majority of Standard Reviews have no experience listed. Now, I realize that the section says that experience is optional, but should it be? Do you prefer to
...
more
Since I have been on the editing rotation this time, I have been noticing that the vast majority of Standard Reviews have no experience listed. Now, I realize that the section says that experience is optional, but should it be? Do you prefer to read reviews that include experience? Do you rate a review lower if there is no experience included?
less
06/23/2012
i think it should
07/06/2012
Quote:
I like hearing about peoples personal experience with a product I just dont like it when that takes up the whole review! And where the heck did the bacon part come from?! Were you craving it when you were writing this?! but bacon is awesome..cooked right
Originally posted by
Ms. N
Since I have been on the editing rotation this time, I have been noticing that the vast majority of Standard Reviews have no experience listed. Now, I realize that the section says that experience is optional, but should it be? Do you prefer to
...
more
Since I have been on the editing rotation this time, I have been noticing that the vast majority of Standard Reviews have no experience listed. Now, I realize that the section says that experience is optional, but should it be? Do you prefer to read reviews that include experience? Do you rate a review lower if there is no experience included?
less
07/06/2012
Quote:
I look for a bit of both when i rate a review simply because i may wnat to know just the info on one then someones personal experiance on another so i can make a better desision
Originally posted by
Ms. N
Since I have been on the editing rotation this time, I have been noticing that the vast majority of Standard Reviews have no experience listed. Now, I realize that the section says that experience is optional, but should it be? Do you prefer to
...
more
Since I have been on the editing rotation this time, I have been noticing that the vast majority of Standard Reviews have no experience listed. Now, I realize that the section says that experience is optional, but should it be? Do you prefer to read reviews that include experience? Do you rate a review lower if there is no experience included?
less
07/20/2012
Quote:
Bacon is awesome! I think experience section should remain optional.
Originally posted by
Ms. N
Since I have been on the editing rotation this time, I have been noticing that the vast majority of Standard Reviews have no experience listed. Now, I realize that the section says that experience is optional, but should it be? Do you prefer to
...
more
Since I have been on the editing rotation this time, I have been noticing that the vast majority of Standard Reviews have no experience listed. Now, I realize that the section says that experience is optional, but should it be? Do you prefer to read reviews that include experience? Do you rate a review lower if there is no experience included?
less
07/20/2012
I've seen a lot of reviews that include personal experiences in the performance area - in my experience, it can be kind of hard to separate the two. That said, I do like to know what the reviewer actually thought about the product from a more personal standpoint - otherwise I'd just read a product description - and it can be hard to cover all the necessary information AND the personal experience in the first section without going over the word limit.
07/20/2012
I don't think it should be mandatory, but I do find it helpful.
07/20/2012
Total posts: 41
Unique posters: 40
- 1
-
2