Goodfella vs VIP Super Soft

Goodfella vs VIP Super Soft

Jack M. Jack M. 11/18/2012

I'm looking for something I can hard pack with. I'm leaning towards the VIP Super Soft at the moment - mostly because I already plan on buying the Mustang, which seems quite similar to the Goodfella in size/texture, and I'd like some variety. Also, it's cheaper.

However, I'm a little worried about the softness of the VIP. Can it be as satisfying as a harder dildo? Does the softness make it useless for hard thrusting? What are your experiences?

Thankyou :]

Invited: All users.

Get Adobe Flash player

Discussion Topics

1.
Jack M. Jack M.
Looking for a dildo for hard packing/gender play.

VIP pros: cheaper, more variety
cons: unsure of the feeling it provides

Goodfella pros: more like an average hard cock
cons: already plan on getting a similar dildo, expensive.
Answers (private voting - your screen name will NOT appear in the results):
53  (96%)
2  (4%)
Total votes: 55
Poll is open
11/18/2012
  • Save 20% on Luxury Toys
  • Save 70%. Limited Quantity
  • Sexy Treats For Her! Gorgeous Gift Set For $60
  • Save 50% on Selected Items
  • Spoil Him! Luxury Gift Set for Men For $60
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
deltalima deltalima
Quote:
Originally posted by Jack M.
Looking for a dildo for hard packing/gender play.

VIP pros: cheaper, more variety
cons: unsure of the feeling it provides

Goodfella pros: more like an average hard cock
cons: already plan on getting a similar dildo, expensive.
I like to Goodfella a bit more.
11/18/2012
indiglo indiglo
I LOVE my Goodfella, that is currently my go-to dildo. The VIP SuperSoft was pretty useless for me, it was so soft and squishy I found it very hard to insert vaginally. Thrusting it was definitely out of the question. It is basically made of the outer, soft layer of the Goodfella with no firm inner core. It's just entirely floppy, squishy, stretchy and bendy.

There are others who really love it, but for packing I don't picture the VIP doing much - especially for hard packing. Although, I think a reviewer Kayla had a good experience with hard packing the VIP.
11/19/2012
Falsepast Falsepast
Definitely Goodfella
11/19/2012
Terri69 Terri69
go with the Goodfella (Vanilla)
11/19/2012
inkky inkky
Goodfella Looks Better
11/19/2012
Jack M. Jack M.
Welp Goodfella seems pretty unanimous. Goodbye, money!
11/19/2012
Ivanna Ivanna
for sure I agree with the others, the Goodfella. Enjoy
11/19/2012
spineyogurt spineyogurt
the goodfella!
11/19/2012
skeeterlynn skeeterlynn
Goodfella.
11/19/2012
srexom srexom
Goodfella
11/19/2012
PropertyOfPotter PropertyOfPotter
Goodfella looks best to me.
11/19/2012
Arlinnae Arlinnae
supersoft looks too soft for me...
11/19/2012
Master DarkWolf Master DarkWolf
First one I guess.
11/19/2012
DreamWolf DreamWolf
Quote:
Originally posted by Master DarkWolf
First one I guess.
I think so too...
11/19/2012
Marie Hanna Marie Hanna
The goodfella. Its more realistic
11/19/2012
Kindred Kindred
I have both dildos and they each have their advantages/disadvantag es. It depends what you're looking for.

Goodfella is a dual density dildo so the firmer inner core makes it easier for thrusting. However, it's a fairly "average" dildo size. Also, the unusual base design makes use in a harness different than with standard bases. It's too firm to be worn under clothes discreetly.

The VIP Super Soft is larger than the measurements on the product page (I reviewed it and made comparison pictures with the Goodfella). It definitely gives a fuller sensation than Goodfella. However, because it is so soft, it is not as easy to thrust quickly with it, though thrusting is possible. The other advantage of the VIP Super Soft is that you can wear it under clothes discreetly since it is so soft and flexible.

Neither my wife nor I have any experience packing. However, Goodfella is probably her go to dildo.
11/19/2012
Missmarc Missmarc
Quote:
Originally posted by Jack M.
Looking for a dildo for hard packing/gender play.

VIP pros: cheaper, more variety
cons: unsure of the feeling it provides

Goodfella pros: more like an average hard cock
cons: already plan on getting a similar dildo, expensive.
Goodfella (Vanilla)
11/19/2012
spiced spiced
Goodfella, no question. It would create a more believable bulge and it's A LOT more useful for actual play. The VIP is a quality toy, but Goodfella is a true classic!
11/22/2012
nosrslylol nosrslylol
Something about a penis and the words "super soft" just doesn't sit right with me, so I vote Goodfella! Haha.
11/22/2012
llellsee llellsee
I'd splurge and get the Goodfella for its realism
11/24/2012
SiNn SiNn
Quote:
Originally posted by Jack M.
Looking for a dildo for hard packing/gender play.

VIP pros: cheaper, more variety
cons: unsure of the feeling it provides

Goodfella pros: more like an average hard cock
cons: already plan on getting a similar dildo, expensive.
good fella
11/25/2012
ASpiritedSlut ASpiritedSlut
I have the VIP Supersoft, and I really think it is entirely too soft for use. I can't even insert it, I think thrusting would be impossible.
11/25/2012
Stinkytofu10 Stinkytofu10
Quote:
Originally posted by Jack M.
Looking for a dildo for hard packing/gender play.

VIP pros: cheaper, more variety
cons: unsure of the feeling it provides

Goodfella pros: more like an average hard cock
cons: already plan on getting a similar dildo, expensive.
Goodfella (Vanilla)
12/12/2012
Real or memorex Real or memorex
"Supersoft" isn't something most people want out of their experience.
12/13/2012
Bubaloo Bubaloo
Vixskin. Always Vixskin. My girl agrees.
02/04/2013
Total posts: 26
Unique posters: 25