Johnny VixSkin vs Goodfella

Johnny VixSkin vs Goodfella

mnc5051 mnc5051 11/08/2010

Looking to purchase a new toy

Invited: All users.

Get Adobe Flash player

Discussion Topics

mnc5051 mnc5051
Pros and cons of both of these products.
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
Sir , Lio , Lady Marmelade , Anjulie , Kindred , tickle me pink , ily , thebest , Artishok , Mr. E , Real or memorex , ashboo32
Gunsmoke , Sir , Waterfall , lamira , Alegria , Sebmissive , dv8 , Envy , meganthomas , ellejay , Red Riding Hood , CynicallyYours , Xavier7 , Miss T , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , navigator-d , BadgersRose , Drifter86 , Kaltir , SexyTabby , Alys , sixfootsex , potstickers , Solar Ray , The Curious Couple , NarcissisticLust , 3d3n1 , Jazz , Devz , ichwillwaffels , kelaaa33wish , deletedacct , CAKES , sarki , Sinfully , Steve of Eden , dezzydezire , Lucky21 , pfoof , Howells , jay28 , Ghost , Pinkhare , sasweetheart89 , lanky , Rhazya , boobookittyfuk , Callisto , SiNn , Miss Anonymous , Keegski , Breas , Beck , Rawhide , Love Perpetua , geliebt , Jon S , jacki , MissCandyland , LavenderSkies , unfulfilled , satinlady550 , Gluesnffr , PropertyOfPotter , padmeamidala , roskat , Missmarc , Stinkytofu10 , spiced , Bethy Cassatt , Lady Smile , ginnyluvspotter , Bleu , TrenchcoatHunters
Total votes: 86 (85 voters)
Poll is open
  • Save 80% on Selected Items. Limited Quantity
  • Sexy Treats For Her! Gorgeous Gift Set For $60
  • The Complete Lovers Kit! Expert Couples Gift Set For $60
  • Spoil Him! Luxury Gift Set for Men For $60
  • Cool Off With 50% Off Selected Items
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
One difference is the Goodfella is 1-3/4" and the Johnny VixSkin is 1-7/8" - which may be something to consider. My wife can handle 1.75" about anytime - larger than that we use only occasionally. We have the Johnny VixSkin on our wish list - but I can't offer any hard advice.
Sir Sir
Really, really depends on what you're wanting. If you want to go with something that has its testicles in the front and looks more realistic, I'd go with the Goodfella. If you have more of a size Queen/King in your hands, then go with Johnny because it is bigger. They're both excellent - I recommend buying both when you have the money.
Waterfall Waterfall
If you can handle the 1 7/8 inch diameter of Johnny Vixskin then I would highly recommend it. I was unsure about whether or not I could handle that size but the give of the material makes Vixskin easier to take than other materials. I am a little biased in the poll though because I LOVE my Johnny
lamira lamira
I personally am not too crazy about realistic dildos, but if I had to buy one, I would choose Johnny VixSkin. It is the most normal looking and I like the size.
Red Riding Hood Red Riding Hood
I voted Johnny. He's beautiful!
Xavier7 Xavier7
The Goodfellas balls look weird to me. It's just that a penis's balls aren't that high.
BadgersRose BadgersRose
Johnny looks really impressive to me.
SexyTabby SexyTabby
Johnny is on my wish list
Alys Alys
My Johnny is on his way!
Anjulie Anjulie
JOhnny is too big for me--I love my goodfella though
thecookiemonster thecookiemonster
I have a johnny on the way too. was thinking about the goodfella as well at some stage, but it's a bit too small in my opinion... plus it doesn't have that curve!!
3d3n1 3d3n1
I have Goodfella, and the dimensions listed on the Eden site are incorrect. It's definitely not 5.5" around, even at the widest part right above the balls - which I just measured at 4.75"

It's the same size as the Mustang, just less usable length due to the balls. And that lost length at the base is the thickest part of the Mustang, at about 5".

The Johnny is a substantially larger toy than Goodfella.
ichwillwaffels ichwillwaffels
Originally posted by mnc5051
Pros and cons of both of these products.
Johnny would be my first choice
deletedacct deletedacct
Johnny in caramel?
l'amour l'amour
I own both, and I must say that I really do enjoy Johnny a lot better than the Goodfella, but maybe that's because I like the girth a lot more.

It just depends on what you want.
Sinfully Sinfully
I haven't used either but Johnny looks more appealing to me.
lanky lanky
go with johny
SiNn SiNn
Originally posted by mnc5051
Pros and cons of both of these products.
really dont like the good fella much even in looks
Miss Anonymous Miss Anonymous
I vote for Johnny! He seems like he'd be the most fun.
Love Perpetua Love Perpetua
I'd go with Johnny - he is more visually appealing to me, and I think the extra girth + curve will be nice.
geliebt geliebt
I would go with johnny because of the girth.
MissCandyland MissCandyland
LavenderSkies LavenderSkies
Originally posted by mnc5051
Pros and cons of both of these products.
Johnny VixSkin looks great to me.
Artishok Artishok
Goodfella for me.
Gluesnffr Gluesnffr
Johnny VixSkin (Vanilla)
PropertyOfPotter PropertyOfPotter
I don't have either, but I think Johnny looks better.
Real or memorex Real or memorex
Johnny is a bit bigger than I want. Goodfella looks like a great dildo if you want the balls.
Bleu Bleu
Johnny is good if you want something smaller. Vixskin is so awesome owo
TrenchcoatHunters TrenchcoatHunters
Originally posted by mnc5051
Pros and cons of both of these products.
Johnny all the way!
ashboo32 ashboo32
Total posts: 31
Unique posters: 31