The New Intimacy

What's your favorite REALISTIC dildo color?

Skip to last post
Set alerts
Updates
Forum search
Contributor: Nothere Nothere
I noticed that there are pretty much three colors for realistic dildos, with a variation of names for the three. Which do you prefer and why? It's an interesting thing to think about. I can't help but wonder, when reading reviews for realistic dildos, why the reviewer happened to choose a certain shade.

I only have the Tantus O2 Adam, but I always wishlist the dildos in caramel...mostly because I love to eat caramels!
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
Vanilla/Beige/Peach
Chirple , Ryuson , jay28 , coconut1 , rom323 , Kallisto , Zombirella , LilLostLenore , cmm , mpfm , Rin (aka Nire) , LAndJ , kawigrl , married with children , - Kira - , solita , Rawhide , Jasco , GONE! , Kendrir , EndlessFrost , Piña Colada , destinationtwilight , nakedbear , Incendiaire , Beck , CanadianChick , LoneOokami , Beautiful-Disaster
29  (58%)
Caramel
Nothere , DeliciousSurprise , Rainbow Boy , Shellz31 , JackRaiden , Buttercup Green , Love Perpetua , potstickers , sunflower , bog , Intrepid Niddering
11  (22%)
Brown/Chocolate
Antipova , Greenleaf , Jake'n'bake , twelve13
4  (8%)
It Varies
slynch , PeaceToTheMiddleEast , JewelsAndB , ddd masturbator(bye all!) , eeep , Mx.Nekora
6  (12%)
Whichever is in stock
Total votes: 50
Poll is closed
01/02/2012
  • Treat Her! Gift Set For Women For $69.99 Only
  • Complete lovers gift set
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Long-distance pleasure set for couples
  • Save Extra 20% On Love Cushion And Toy Set!
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: Chirple Chirple
I've been looking at a few lately, and like the ones that are close to my own skin tone. That way, if I use them in a harness, it's visually closer to being an extension of myself, I guess.
01/02/2012
Contributor: Rainbow Boy Rainbow Boy
Great question! I like the caramel/mocha colored ones. I used to get my realistic dildos in vanilla/cream all the time, but then I noticed that the color didn't look too realistic at all. It's just too pale. Caramel definitely appears much more natural.
01/02/2012
Contributor: Nothere Nothere
I really wish they would have a better selection of colors. I think that the caramel being more natural has alot to do with why I love it!
01/02/2012
Contributor: Ryuson Ryuson
(Review Program Mentor)
I like ones close to my own skin tone, I feel a bit inappropriate now for not wishlisting a broader variety of skin tones!
01/02/2012
Contributor: Zombirella Zombirella
Quote:
Originally posted by Nothere
I noticed that there are pretty much three colors for realistic dildos, with a variation of names for the three. Which do you prefer and why? It's an interesting thing to think about. I can't help but wonder, when reading reviews for ... more
Color doesn't really matter to me
01/03/2012
Contributor: LilLostLenore LilLostLenore
Quote:
Originally posted by Zombirella
Color doesn't really matter to me
same here color dont matter to me either.
01/03/2012
Contributor: cmm cmm
The only one I have is my skin tone.
01/03/2012
Contributor: Rin (aka Nire) Rin (aka Nire)
I prefer vanilla, since my own skin is fairly pale, even though I know that real penises are typically a bit darker than the skin around them. Though I have seen pictures and videos of pale chaps with equally pale cocks - I guess the real thing varies quite a bit in this regard.
01/03/2012
Contributor: LAndJ LAndJ
Vanilla/Beige/Peach because it's more realistic to my man.
01/03/2012
Contributor: kawigrl kawigrl
i have vanilla and caramel, they both are pretty nice
01/03/2012
Contributor: PeaceToTheMiddleEast PeaceToTheMiddleEast
Have not purchased any yet but I would try them all to see what I liked best.
01/03/2012
Contributor: - Kira - - Kira -
I usually go with the palest option as I am super pale myself. Also it seems the least realistic and as I'm not really a fan of the realistic look so it appeals to me the most. I much prefer fun colors, but I like realistic materials. What's a girl to do?
01/03/2012
Contributor: Antipova Antipova
So brown is my favorite color. The chocolate realistic color looks so pretty to me, and matches my room!

That said, my first ever 'realistic' dildo I got in caramel, because it looks more realistic to me.

My only "mocha/chocolate& quot; realistic dildos are the VIP supersoft, and Mark Supersoft, which are really sort of stylized realistic, and look so nice and pretty.

I'm currently trying to pick whether I want a caramel VixSkin Buck or chocolate... I know that's my next realistic cock but I just can't choose which color! Maybe it'll come down to a sale and which one's in stock during the sale.
01/03/2012
Contributor: Rawhide Rawhide
If I want the realistic to match my skin tone, then it's gotta be one of the caucasian ones... but I think some companies do it better than others. I'm happy with the VixSkin vanilla color, but the O2 cream is almost as white as, well, actual cream. Unless we're playing a medical scene, I'm not partial to totally white toys.

I do think that Tantus's caramel tone is prettier than Vixen's though.
01/03/2012
Contributor: Cherry21 Cherry21
Quote:
Originally posted by Nothere
I noticed that there are pretty much three colors for realistic dildos, with a variation of names for the three. Which do you prefer and why? It's an interesting thing to think about. I can't help but wonder, when reading reviews for ... more
I keep looking at the realistic ones, and I just can't get into it for some reason. I feel like I know its fake, so its fake. Kinda like it hot pink colored! lol, I get the appeal though, and have tried to get into them for the sake of trying new things.
01/03/2012
Contributor: GONE! GONE!
Ones that match my skin in case I decide to use it for harness play...
01/04/2012
Contributor: Love Perpetua Love Perpetua
I usually lust after the caramel ones, but I don't have a realistic colored one yet!
01/08/2012
Contributor: ddd masturbator(bye all!) ddd masturbator(bye all!)
Quote:
Originally posted by Nothere
I noticed that there are pretty much three colors for realistic dildos, with a variation of names for the three. Which do you prefer and why? It's an interesting thing to think about. I can't help but wonder, when reading reviews for ... more
I prefer guys that have brown skin...

I like dildos that are categorized as caramel, brown, or black, but have yet to get one. Truthfully, the color of the realistic dildo doesn't matter that much to me. But I imagine that if I were dating someone, I'd want a fake cock the same color as him.
01/08/2012
Contributor: eeep eeep
I tend to like lighter colored flesh tones, since I am so pale they don't contrast too much. The cream color of Tantus is too light for me though, it just looks unrealistic in that shade. I have one in caramel, black, and mocha so far. Sad to see they are discontinuing the mocha, because I actually like it best now that I have one in it. It looks like chocolate.
01/08/2012
Contributor: RonLee RonLee
How about a NON-flesh color!
PITCH or JET BLACK
LIME GREEN
HOT PINK
PURPLE
ANYTHING BUT ANYONE'S FLESH COLOR!
01/08/2012
Contributor: Greenleaf Greenleaf
If I have to pick a "flesh tone" color, I go with mocha/chocolate - it's generally the richest/prettiest color. I feel like the cream/caramel tones usually don't have enough of a pink undertone to them and end up looking like ken-doll dicks, which is pretty unappealing to me. If I were choosing a toy for harness play it'd have to be a very(extremely) pale cream.

I vastly prefer non-flesh tones - the more pearly, metallic, sparkly, neon, or glowy the better.
01/09/2012
Contributor: Mx.Nekora Mx.Nekora
I love Black/Caramel colored cause it reminds me of my lover. But i love multicolored as well.
02/22/2012
Contributor: destinationtwilight destinationtwilight
Quote:
Originally posted by Nothere
I noticed that there are pretty much three colors for realistic dildos, with a variation of names for the three. Which do you prefer and why? It's an interesting thing to think about. I can't help but wonder, when reading reviews for ... more
If I was going for realistic I would go for a lighter color.
02/22/2012
Contributor: destinationtwilight destinationtwilight
Quote:
Originally posted by destinationtwilight
If I was going for realistic I would go for a lighter color.
I also like multicolored or colorful ones.
02/22/2012
Contributor: nakedbear nakedbear
I dont really like flesh toned ones...
02/22/2012
Contributor: Incendiaire Incendiaire
I'm not a big fan of flesh-coloured toys, but if that's the only option for something I want, then I tend to lend towards the peachy ones, just so long as the colour isn't too insipid.
02/22/2012
Contributor: Beck Beck
Not a fan of flesh colored, but if I got one it would be palest you could get. I think they look the least realistic, so that is what I would be going for.
02/22/2012
Contributor: LoneOokami LoneOokami
vanilla cause it matches my skin
05/09/2013
Contributor: sunflower sunflower
I'm always interested in the caramel. That white usually is TOO white.
05/10/2013