Wow, I certainly know how overwhelming this can be. I bought my first toy on Eden just last year! It really depends on your price range and if you're used to insertion. And... your gender, actually. You didn't list a gender. Respond with your gender and I'll start putting together a list!

Hahaha, then it isn't your first! What all are you looking for to expand your collection, then?

Awesome! When you're really not sure what you're interested in getting, I really don't recommend throwing more than $50 at a toy. That way you don't have a toy you hate that you dropped $150 on and have to find someone to buy it off you used for $30 or something.

The two that are on the top of my list are the Harmonia and the Bgood Deluxe. The Harmonia does have a bit of a battery compartment malfunction that I had to get replaced, but otherwise they're both body safe and have a ton of patterns.

The Tryst 1 is also an affordable silicone toy that is pretty small. It's not the most powerful, but I still find myself going back to it quite often.

The Seduction and the Diamond Fairy are both AWESOME toys that are pretty cheap. They're both plastic and very firm, but I highly suggest them for both internal and external use.

Lastly, if you're super on a budget, the cheapest, insertable toy that I have that can hold its own is the Rocker Vibe 7. It's fairly strong and quiet, and it has held up well to multiple uses.

I hope that I was some help! The trick is that you don't want to go TOO cheap, but you also don't want to go too expensive. Most of my favorite toys are in the $30-$50 range and I have a lot, so start with something cheap and fairly simple.

Let me know what you decide on!