Which water-based lubricant is best-suited for a die-hard pjur Original Bodyglide fan?

I primarily use silicone lubricants. I have just the one silicone toy atm but am purchasing another today and I know i don't have a ton of my first water-based lube, Sliquid Organics Gel, left. I'm looking for something that is closer to a silicone-lube feel/consistency/etc and that lasts long, doesn't need much reapplication, is silky/smooth/velvety/l uxurious feeling, is neither too thick nor too thin, etc. -- all of the traits that make pjur's Original Bodyglide (my go-to silicone lube of several years) so wonderful. Anyway, I've narrowed down my choices based on product info, reviews, etc, but still am not sure which lubricant to go with... puhleeeeeeze help me out???

Invited: All reviewers.

Discussion Topics

Contributor: Kake aka PoeticErotica Kake aka PoeticErotica
I'm looking for the best and most silicone-lube-like water-based lubricant I can find. Silicone lube-wise, I'm partial to pjur's Eros Original Bodyglide. I've tried other water-based lubes before, my favorite and the most recent being Sliquid Organics Gel. However, I'm definitely ready to upgrade to something more along the lines of what I like from a lube. Please choose the lube(s) you think are closest to what I'd like! Thank you for your feedback and input! <3
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
potstickers , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , Kindred , dv8 , Pink Jewel , Jon S , jay28 , Kate , GONE! , eeep , K101 , Silverdrop , Breas , fufucat , DreamWolf , Clubbinseals , Chefbriapink , thesquaredeific , Eva Schwaltz , Falsepast , mmmmm
Total votes: 23 (23 voters)
Poll is open
  • Save Extra 50% On Sexobot Attachment
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Save 70% On Selected Items. Limited Quantity
  • Complete strap-on set for extra 15% off
  • Save 50% On Shower Nozzle With Enema Set
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: Kindred Kindred
Liquid Silk is the only lube I've tried of the choices you listed. To be honest, no water based lube is going to feel as slick or last as long as a silicone based lube. Liquid Silk is good but it does contain parabens, has an awful taste (not always an issue), and gets sticky to me when it dries. Other water based lubes that I personally prefer would be Sliquid JO H2O (still has parabens) and Sliquid Sassy booty Formula. Sliquid Sassy dries a little faster than the H2O but is all natural.
Contributor: Kate Kate
out of these, liquid silk. i hear rave reviews about it!
Contributor: eeep eeep
Liquid silk is actually a hybrid lube. It is mostly water-based, but has a small amount of silicone in it (the dimethicone in the ingredients). From what I hear and have noticed with the Sliquid organics silk (also a hybrid) there is not enough silicone in there to cause a reaction with a silicone toy. I would still spot test it on a toy before trying it to be safe, which I did when I tried the sliquid with one. I had no issues and I do love the sliquid organics silk, but I hear good things about liquid silk too.
Contributor: K101 K101
LOVE LOVE LOVE Liquid Silk, but it actually does contain Dimethicone. It may still be safe for SOME silicone, but I don't use it with silicone toys. I personally am not a fan of Pink. I think it's messy and just ick! I've yet to try all of the Pink lubes though. I love Liquid Silk much more than Sliquid. I actually got a new full bottle of it today!

With the Sliquid, it's true, there's hardly ANY Dimethicone. Not enough to disturb your toys. It's not even noticeable on the skin. Not silky to me.

Hope you find a great one!
Contributor: Silverdrop Silverdrop
I've only used Liquid Silk of the ones listed, and I have never had a problem with it and my Tantus or JeJoue silicone toys. You can also try spot testing your Pjur on the toys - it's possible you won't have to give it up at all, as it's only some lubes and some toys that have the reaction.
Contributor: Sangsara Sangsara
only one i've tried kama sutra makes great products tho even if they are a little expensive
Contributor: Clubbinseals Clubbinseals
I love liquid silk. Its been my favorite lube iv ever tried.
Contributor: Chefbriapink Chefbriapink
Originally posted by Kate
out of these, liquid silk. i hear rave reviews about it!
yes. me too!
Contributor: thesquaredeific thesquaredeific
Liquid Silk.
Contributor: Eva Schwaltz Eva Schwaltz
Out of those I would pick the Liquid silk, but I don't like Pink Water or Toko aqua because they are way too watery.
Contributor: Falsepast Falsepast
Of these, Liquid Silk
Contributor: mmmmm mmmmm
Liquid silk