Classic butt plug medium by Doc Johnson - review by KatPawz2003

You Get What You Pay For

This is one of the cheapest toys I have ever made the mistake of buying. While at first glance it looks like it would be good, it has a heavy fragrance upon opening, is too large for a beginner (or, like, me non-regular anal player), and will fall apart. What do you expect for only $10 though? Just save your money and buy something of a better quality and anatomy appropriate size.
Phthalate Free
Large for a non-regular anal lover
Not for beginners
Falls apart
Smells fruity even after wash
Rating by reviewer:
useful review


The “Classic Butt Plug” is only a classic in shape. It may actually be using the original design and material from who knows how long ago. It is made of what they claim to be a “non-phthalate” rubber, but there is nothing to back up this claim. Rubber is a porous material, so if you should decide to use share this you will need to use a condom over it each time. The wide base makes it easy to retrieve and the thinness of the neck makes it easy to stay once in place. You could wear this for extended periods if you choose to, but the base may become a little bit uncomfortable over time.

I really would not recommend this to anyone as it will fall apart just from occasional use.
  • Who / How / What
    [ ? ]
    Who might this product be best for? How is it best used? What are the best circumstances or situations for using this product?
    • Couples
    • Everyone
    • Solo
  • Where
    [ ? ]
    Where / what types of places can this product be used?
    • Anywhere
  • Body / part areas
    [ ? ]
    What areas on the body can this product be used / what areas does it stimulate best?
    • Anal

Material / Texture

This toy is made out of rubber and holds a strong fruity smell which will hit you when you open the package. This smell does get weaker over time, but after over a year of being too lazy to trash it, I can still smell it. Rubber is porous, which is why the smell still lingers after all of this time. It also makes it so that you are not able to sterilize it, so you may want to consider using a condom with it. They claim that it is phthalate free rubber, but it is not known if this is truly the case. The rubber has a soft, smooth, squishy outer shell. There is a little bit of air space before you hit the firmer, yet still flexible, inner core.
    • Porous
    • Smooth
    • Strong odor

Design / Shape / Size

It has an outer portion and inner portion and a cover which holds the inner core in. The cover has a seam which connects it to the outer shell. This seam is what will break, and once it does you are not actually able to remove the inner core if you want. The best that you can do is to take a pair of cutters and clip the narrow neck portion of the core. This will allow you to remove the end piece and put something else, like a tail, in its place. You will have to find a compatible adhesive to be able to hold anything in though; rubber cement is an option although I do not know the safety level of doing something of this type.

Overall it is 5 ½” long and 1 ¾” in diameter with the insertable length being only 5”. The neck is about ¾” in diameter. The base is ½” thick, 3” long, and a little over 1 4/5” wide. The most comfortable way to wear it is with the length of the base running from front to back.

This is more of a size for intermediate users and advanced users who do not like to be stretched too much. Beginners will find this to be not only intimidating but also painful if they try it.
    • Ergonomic
    • Partner play
    • Traditional


Honestly, there is not much that I can say is good about this toy other than the price. It is cheaply made, falls apart in a short amount of time, and really is not what I would consider to be an average sized plug. They took the traditional plug shape and used shoddy construction to come up with this horror.
    • Not discreet at all

Care and Maintenance

Care is simple with this - just use toy cleaner or soap and water to wash it and store it where it won't touch other materials. My suggestion is to put it in a bag of some sort so that it is less likely to be damaged while not in use. Oil based lubes will melt the rubber, so stick to water or silicone based please. They are not discreet at all so store it somewhere where unwanted eyes will not find it. You can keep it in a drawer or somewhere with a little bit of space to it.
    • Easy to clean
    • Easy to store

Personal comments

The core separated from the outer shell at the external seam about a month into owning it. Part of the reason why I haven't thrown it away is the fact that I am considering trying to make my own tail plug at some point.
Follow-up commentary
I was going to try and make a tail out of it, but I have decided that it isn't worth wasting a tail on. Just buy something better quality, and for tails either buy one or use one that attaches to a plug with a ring on it.
This content is the opinion of the submitting contributor and is not endorsed by
Become a Reviewer. Get free toys. Enjoy Special Deals
This review was edited by
  • PassionCpl PassionCpl
  • Rank:
  • Edited reviews: 115
Discussion Posts Last Update
Material safety 6
excited 3
Thank you for viewing Classic butt plug medium review page!