Originally posted by
Eww, I would not eat Crisco, nor use it for lube. Coconut oil, maybe.
Coconut oil isn't very good for anal play because it melts and becomes very thin.
I use Crisco sometimes. For a big silicone toy it doesn't have the problem of being "squeegeed off" by the anus, but it is very thick so it only works for slow moving toys.
I can't see Vaseline being a good thing for any sort of sex lube.
For anal use I don't worry about oil-based lubes. They'll come out soon enough to not cause a problem.