On an unrelated note - Montessori

Contributor: Dragon Dragon
I've been listening to several debates recently that resolve around the professional side of my life. Montessori Education. The key issue appears to be how much of the general population knows about Montessori education and what their thoughts are about Montessori (positive and negative.

I know a lot about a lot of the people on this forum through other threads - age demographics, children, etc. It's really an ideal mix to run this question by you. I'd love to hear your comments.

Have you heard about Montessori? What do you think it is? Would you send your child to a Montessori school? Why or why not? Do you think all Montessori schools are about the same?

Thanks...
03/08/2010
  • Treat Her! Gift Set For Women For $69.99 Only
  • Complete lovers gift set
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Long-distance pleasure set for couples
  • Save Extra 20% On Love Cushion And Toy Set!
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: removedacnt removedacnt
Quote:
Originally posted by Dragon
I've been listening to several debates recently that resolve around the professional side of my life. Montessori Education. The key issue appears to be how much of the general population knows about Montessori education and what their thoughts ... more
Interesting! So you're a teacher?

Ok all that I know about Montessori is that it's a different way of teaching children. I'm assuming it focuses more on a child's individual learning styles. I also believe they incorporate music, and real life type learning than regular schools. Am I close to right?

Would I send my children to a Montessori school? Yes, but only if I had the money, it's quite expensive, and if I had not chosen to homeschool.

And on the last question, I have no idea. I would assume in some ways yes and in some ways no. How's that for definitive answer?
03/08/2010
Contributor: Miss Jane Miss Jane
Quote:
Originally posted by Dragon
I've been listening to several debates recently that resolve around the professional side of my life. Montessori Education. The key issue appears to be how much of the general population knows about Montessori education and what their thoughts ... more
I've never heard of it.

Honestly, I thought it was hybrid of "Montana" and "Missouri"...
03/08/2010
Contributor: Dragon Dragon
Quote:
Originally posted by Miss Jane
I've never heard of it.

Honestly, I thought it was hybrid of "Montana" and "Missouri"...
OH MY GOD... LOL. I'll fill you in a bit later hopefully after more answers.
03/08/2010
Contributor: Sir Sir
I've never heard of that, but I have heard of Waldorf schools. I am thinking that perhaps it's a similar idea.
03/08/2010
Contributor: Miss Jane Miss Jane
Quote:
Originally posted by Dragon
OH MY GOD... LOL. I'll fill you in a bit later hopefully after more answers.
Seriously I sat here for a moment going, "WTF, Montana and Missouri don't border each other!", because I was thinking of other area-combined names like "Michiana".

Probably just b/c I don't have kids, and went to public school.
03/08/2010
Contributor: Miss Cinnamon Miss Cinnamon
Once upon a time, I went to a Montessori elementary school. I didn't stay there for long; my parents couldn't afford it!

From what I do remember (I was very, very young), they taught reading and simple math starting at the preschool level. I don't know if that's standard for preschools/lower elementary grades, but I felt that the expectations were higher. The youngest children were first taught how to count to ten, and then to 100, and then given little math booklets to do which taught "fact families" for addition and subtraction. They also taught us to read, and there was a little lending library of "Bug in a Rug" type books. Aside from the "academics", younger children performed exercises that developed fine and gross motor skills, like pouring liquid from a pitcher into a cup, perforating the outlines of a picture with a pin, etc.

Older children were given more complicated things to learn, like the names of all the body parts (predictably, the "private parts" were skimmed over). They seemed to always be up to something exciting, but I never found out what it was, as I transferred to a public elementary school before I could.

One thing I remember about the Montessori school I went to that I miss is the individual attention that the teachers gave each student. Every child was able to learn at his or her own pace instead of being held back or left behind by the "average learning speed".

The teachers also knew how to "push" students to learn new things. I remember being bored one day and going to the station where I poured liquid from one pitcher into another. One of the teachers stopped me and said, "No, that's for babies. You're old enough to learn something new now." And she found me something else to do. That's something that your typical public school classroom doesn't do, and probably can't afford to do. Of course, my knowledge is limited by both the short amount of time I spent at the school and how young I was when I attended.

If I could afford it, I would definitely send my child(ren) to a Montessori school. I'd probably do more extensive research first though.
03/08/2010
Contributor: Tuesday Tuesday
My son went to Montessori school for a few years. We thought it was great. He did Kindergarten in both Montessori school (mornings) and public school (afternoons). I can't remember why we did that.

When it was time to sign him up for first grade we gave him a choice and he picked public school. But we have only positive things to say about Montessori school.

What's interesting is that during teacher conferences, his Montessori teacher said he was ahead in math and a little behind in reading. The public school teacher said he was ahead in reading and behind in math.
03/08/2010
Contributor: EffinSara EffinSara
I went to a Montessori pre-school. I was so young that I can't remember a whole lot of it, but I do know that at age 4 I understood plant reproduction and the life cycle of bats, and I could read and do basic math. I remember being frustrated by the transition from Montessori to public elementary, where I was already so far ahead of the other children and was regularly pulled out of class for more advanced one-on-one classes. I'm not sure I ever fully adjusted. I feel like I personally would have been better served by Montessori-style elementary school, but I can't say what it would have been like for me had I not done it for pre-school.
03/08/2010
Contributor: MuffysPinguLove MuffysPinguLove
Quote:
Originally posted by Miss Jane
I've never heard of it.

Honestly, I thought it was hybrid of "Montana" and "Missouri"...
I have to agree with Miss Jane I thought it was a typo/ montana missouri combination...
03/08/2010
Contributor: Miss Cinnamon Miss Cinnamon
Quote:
Originally posted by EffinSara
I went to a Montessori pre-school. I was so young that I can't remember a whole lot of it, but I do know that at age 4 I understood plant reproduction and the life cycle of bats, and I could read and do basic math. I remember being frustrated ... more
That's pretty much how I felt about the transition, too.

I vaguely remember learning about plant reproduction and being like "Heh. Stamen's a funny word." I'm pretty sure I didn't get to learn about the life cycle of bats while I was at Montessori, which is a shame, because bats? Are awesome.
03/08/2010
Contributor: Sammi Sammi
We had one Montessori pre-school here, but the waiting list was astronomically long to get in, so we didn't send our kids there.
03/08/2010
Contributor: J's Alley J's Alley
Ok...this could get lengthy so I apologize.

As for kids under 6 it is a well balanced program, assuming the child has parents who do educational things at home as well. Any age over that I would be hesitant because of grouping. Having said that, I do think, when executed properly and with a well trained teacher, the program is great. I believe this because it functions much like a lot of homeschool programs do, and doesn't force knowledge the child isn't ready to handle yet.

I do believe that removing a child from Montessori and placing them into a public school can be problematic. In some classrooms teachers don't like to bend, so a child who won't learn well with just listening can be stunted as far as learning because they are used to more aspects in a lesson. However, the private school my daughters attend incorporate a lot of that styling and my daughters tend to teach themselves, which is refreshing for me to see. Adults read to gain knowledge, and children play to gain it...essentially it works well.

Not all schools are alike. We have one near us that is a joke, and there are several schools that "apply" the teachings (doing so incorrectly). I never sent my girls to one because the price is just disgusting (I literally pay 1/2 of what the preschool cost for elementary private school).
03/08/2010
Contributor: Dragon Dragon
In brief -

Maria Montessori developed a system of education based on observation of children 100 years ago. She started by working with mentally deficient children. When they passed the school examinations with better results than regular school children she was wondering what was wrong with traditional schools. A question that many people still ask. Why are schools so bad, boring, frustrating and wrong for my child?

Montessori education is designed around the concept of "Follow the child." Observation of the child will allow the teacher to know the child and to provide the materials and lessons that the child is ready to learn the most right now. In other words - child driven rather than teacher driven. It focuses on choice and interest. When done right, it can have very high academic results.

As pointed out- there is a huge difference in the quality of Montessori schools. There are many reasons for this. As for cost, usually the cost of a Montessori preschool is comparable to a well-run traditional preschool.

Let me know if you want to know more, and I'm glad to hear your comments!
03/10/2010