Probe or plug for anal non-virgin who's out of practice?

Contributor: Ollie Vee Ollie Vee
I'm poring through various toy suggestions and I'm scratching my head. There's plenty of suggestions for anal newbies but they don't seem to be what I need. I have had past experience (fingers, beads, those weird '80s sparkly plugs that gave me an itch, and penises) but it's years and I'm way out of practice. I'm not considering beads after an accident with a bead cord snapping. Thankfully no beads went missing so no ER visit but that was no fun getting the stuck ones out! >_< I know, I know, toys have changed for the better and safer but I have no trust in beads, plus I always found them hard to get in (too flexible).

What I'm interested in is a graduated type plug or probe that has a fairly small starting tip. I have a Glass Probe but I can only use it for vaginal play, it's too heavy and the first bump was uncomfortably large and I don't know what made me bleed, if it was a dormant hemorrhoid or if it was a case of oops, too big I'd like something that's easy to clean and not super-bendy. Maybe I'll have to forget about the series-of-bloops probes and go with a plug, much as I like the feel of the bloops?
  • Save Extra 50% On Sexobot Attachment
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Save 70% On Selected Items. Limited Quantity
  • Complete strap-on set for extra 15% off
  • Save 50% On Shower Nozzle With Enema Set
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: GingerAnn GingerAnn
Relevant topic analysis on Anal probe:

Syphilis probe underway in the porn world
The Free Speech Coalition has called for a production moratorium and performer testing after an actor recently tested positive for syphilis. Right...

plug vs. probe
Whats the better choice for a beginner? any suggestions on a certain one?

Plug or Probe?
Personally, I love a good plug. I wanted to see what peoples preferences are.

Pulse Probe
I just received this in the mail, would anyone recommend this vibrator for anal?

Watter missile probe vs. slim smooth delight
I have a clear preference between these two very similar toys (the water missile) and wonder if anyone else has an opinion.
Contributor: Annemarie Annemarie
If you like bloops and want a plug, go with the Jolly Jack. Best of both worlds.

I wrote a review on it, and I love it. It's medium-sized, and has increasing-sized bloops, so you can be comfortable with each before moving on.

It's flexible, but firm, and it's silicone, so, easy to clean.