This is a tough one for me—I know you don't to spend a lot of money, but perhaps you might consider bumping up your maximum price, or save up Eden Points to reduce the cost. I say this because there are some really good options in the $20-$40 price range, but far fewer good options under $20.

For one thing, you can get a glass or silicone dildo for under $40 and while this may seem like too much to spend, both materials will last indefinitely and are non-porous, so there is no worry of embedded bacterial or material break down over time.

For example, you can get the Tantus Curve which is exactly the size you want and made of 100% silicone for $39.99.

A fairly inexpensive glass option would be Blue Hearts which is $24.99, not too much more than your maximum.

Another option might be this which is made of Sil-a-gel and has anti-bacterial properties. It's in your price and size range, but I have not tried it so I would suggest reading reviews before purchase.

There are many other choices under $20 in the rubber, jelly or cyber-skin material categories, but keep in mind these are porous materials, which can harbor bacterial and the toys I've owned made from these materials have not had a long life.

Save and get one that's better. Silicone or glass are great choices, much better than TPR, rubber or jelly.

Thanks everyone for your advice. I have only used egg vibes and I am trying to pick out a good first dildo.