Can anyone suggest an "upgrade" for me?

Yes I have seen a lot of glass toys that have the shape/size and texture I want, but I'm honestly a little hesitant to try glass. I'm a glass virgin and the fact that it doesn't have any give scares me. I guess I'm afraid I'll hurt myself with it! Which I'm sure I'm most likely being a little paranoid, but I just haven't been able to get past that and buy a glass toy to see what I actually think of it. Maybe it's about time I take the plunge!

Check out some of Evolved's Roulette vibes, they look like they may have a similar texture. ^_^

Glass, from what I hear, is very very durable, so no worries about it breaking, though it could be more rough on the insides.

Thanks nana.inuk! Those look like they might be exactly what I'm looking for!

I definitely second the Roulette vibes by Evolved Novelties. I have a friend who recently purchased the All on Red model, which has more grooves than protrusions than the ones you may be looking into, but she says they are simply fantastic. Smooth silicone, girthy, and prominent texture. You'd probably want the Bet on Black or Lucky 11 based on the vibrator you originally had. You could look into the g-spot ones too if you want a discount at the mo.

However, if you want something similar to the texture and flexibility of jelly without the chemical diffusing or yellowing over time, you can also look into toys made of TPR Silicone which last longer than jelly. They are porous though, but they don't smell or have as high a porosity level like jelly. It's a happy medium if you like the feeling of jelly without the smell and dangers lurking in it. Evolved Novelties also makes a number of these kinds of toys and treat them with the same care as their pure silicone toys. link

Although, if want to treat yourself to a fantastic pure silicone vibrator with similar features to the one you showed us, definitely get one of the Roulettes. Comes in a little plastic storage container too. Evolved is a wonderful company.