Which lube is best? Silicone or water based?

Forum highlights on Silicone vibrators:

silicone vibes are dead to me!!!
I got the Lelo Siri yesterday, and what a letdown after the Nea. I swear I cannot get off clitorally with silicone vibes, I have the JimmyJane form 4,

Silicone vibrator enhancer - can you use them with silicone toys?
Silicone vibrator enhancer - can you use them with silicone toys? Or would the two different materials melt each other? Did anyone try them?

Ripple triple silicone stimulator – g-spot and clitoral vibrator
This one looks amazing, but there's NO discussions about it yet. What do you think ladies; Stud? or Dud?

Fleur De Lis silicone seduction – traditional vibrator
This is cute but how well will it work?

Silicone and plastic toy storage
What is the best way to store silicone and plastic vibrators? I heard that silicone can melt if stored with another silicone toy, is it safe to store.

Well, it depends on preference and what you'd be using with it. If you plan on using that toy you have linked, you should only use water-based. You may like the feel of hybrid lubes, but the silicone on the lube will react with the silicone on that toy and destroy it.

Water based is best for a lot of toys, definitely if it's silicone. If you're bent on using silicone lube or a hybrid then cover the toy with a condom first.

Waterbased for all of my toys!

I use a long-lasting water-based lube (either Blossom Organics or Sliquid Sassy) most of the time.

I use water base ONLY since most of my toys are silicone

I use only water based lube so I don't have to worry about compatibility with my toys.