Silicone can get stained, and you should not let toys touch each other. Next time, make sure to use a condom. The toy's stain will most likely not come off by anything.

Unfortunately, it's most likely a permanent stain. I had something like that happen with my favorite toy; I let it rest against the paper information sheet that had come with the toy, and when I picked it up, there were words on my toy!

That was a few months ago, and the stain hasn't been washed out nor worn off.


It probably won't ever come off, but if it doesn't hurt the integrity of the toy, just cover it with a coloured condom so you won't even have to think about it. Was the second toy silicone, too? How long were they touching?

I thought that non-porous materials wouldn't be able to stain permanently, but I guess not. The second toy was plastic. I keep everything seperated while it's stored but apparently they came into contact for a few minutes while I was using them. I guess I'll just have to try and avoid that in the future. I don't really want to buy condoms just to stop colours from bleeding. And I won't be buying any more white toys because at least if it was coloured the mark wouldn't show so badly.

Now that I think about it, the toy that I had that got lettered up was white, too! Maybe it's just the curse of snow white toys?

I've had it soaking in bleach and water for the last couple hours and the stain is lightening up. I'm gonna leave it in for a few more hours and see what happens.

Oops, didn't know I wasn't supposed to bleach it