If it's something you're both interested in, that's great! Whenever my husband and I try something new that we enjoy, my mind always races as well! I would first make sure that it's something your husband is interested in and willing to explore with you. If it is, you need to make sure you're only using safe items. Anything without a flared base could potentially slip inside of him, causing an unpleasant trip to the emergency room. Your fingers are a great place to start, but using the lube bottle is dangerous, and the vibe could be as well if it doesn't have the flared base. Take a look at some of the anal toys together and see if there's anything he's interested in. Make sure he's comfortable with all of this and then take the next step. Just always make sure you use products that are designed for and safe for anal use!

Like anything new and really enjoyable it will be on your mind for quite some time. It's probably ok till one of you doesn't want to engage in pegging anymore. Might be months or years or never.

sounds like a great time. there are worse things for you to be addicted to. you may want to look into pegging (penetrating him with a strap on) and discussing it with your hubby.

He says he enjoyed it. And I kept asking him during if he was ok. I didn't want to overstep my boundaries.... But I enjoyed it so much it's all I can think about. If I try to initiate again so soon will he run??

I love pegging my sweetie, and I was super pumped about it the first time! After, all I could think about was doing it again. I constantly looked at new ideas or toys I could use on him the next time. Needless to say, I still do this, and I still get just as excited about it. I had to learn to contain my excitement, as we are both "switches." It's all about what works for you and your partner. I can totally understand your feelings, and I think it's wonderful you found something new that you both enjoy! Happy pegging!!

P.S. I agree with PropertyOfPotter, You guys should play it safe!!!