The New Intimacy

Featured by EdenFantasys

Sweet love
Beginner butt plug
Beginner's Guide to Anal Plugs
The Guide to Choosing Anal Plugs
Explore Now
Seduction
Advanced butt plug

What size do you prefer

Skip to last post
Set alerts
Updates
Forum search
Contributor: Zandrock Zandrock
What size of butt plug diameter do you prefer?
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
Two Grand , SoloRebel , karmaqueen , Inquistable
4  (15%)
Sinfully , Orion , solitudinarian , Do emu , squire , skeeterlynn , Gunsmoke , Chou Wang , Missmarc , AmethystSmoke , hotcherry , Soundside46
12  (46%)
Rawr4483 , hhh , potstickers , Lisset Finnien , Fire21 , louise83
6  (23%)
Husband and Wife , Di's Guy , Robin Goodfellow
3  (12%)
ZombieShift
1  (4%)
Total votes: 26
Poll is open
08/05/2012
  • Treat Her! Gift Set For Women For $69.99 Only
  • Complete lovers gift set
  • Upgrade Your Hands-Free Play!
  • Long-distance pleasure set for couples
  • Save Extra 20% On Love Cushion And Toy Set!
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: Sinfully Sinfully
about 1.5 inches.
08/05/2012
Contributor: digit88 digit88
Quote:
Originally posted by Zandrock
What size of butt plug diameter do you prefer?
none
08/05/2012
Contributor: Do emu Do emu
Quote:
Originally posted by Zandrock
What size of butt plug diameter do you prefer?
1.5~
08/06/2012
Contributor: squire squire
1.5 is my ideal for every day use, but I like to move up to 1.75 when I want a stretch...
08/06/2012
Contributor: Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Quote:
Originally posted by squire
1.5 is my ideal for every day use, but I like to move up to 1.75 when I want a stretch...
Me too - looking for a 1.625 as a transition to 1.75.
08/06/2012
Contributor: AmethystSmoke AmethystSmoke
1.5" - I really like my Ryder. I do have to say that I almost never wear a plug except when having sex. Not that I don't like to, just haven't made it a point to wear one long term.

I've just begun to look around for something a little larger to see if I like it but I also need it to be PIV sex-friendly as well as comfortable.
08/10/2012
Contributor: hotcherry hotcherry
1.5 inches
08/10/2012
Contributor: Two Grand Two Grand
I'm just getting started 1 1/4" is where I am am giong to try 1 1/2 soon I just want to see how it will feel. I want it to be pleasureble I don't want to go too big. Maybe if my lady finally wants to get into pegging I still want small diameter things in my butt.
08/11/2012
Contributor: icelandia icelandia
1.5 inches definitely
08/17/2012
Contributor: Gunsmoke Gunsmoke
Quote:
Originally posted by Gunsmoke
Me too - looking for a 1.625 as a transition to 1.75.
I like glass plugs because they have a wider neck than steel and most silicone options. I just found a great 2" glass that I just love. I start with a 1.5" in the shower and switch to the 2" before getting out. It certainly makes taking my wife's Big Dick (her words)(Vixen Outlaw) easier and more fun!
05/29/2017
Contributor: AmethystQueen AmethystQueen
I prefer 2" wide and up and at least 5" insertable. Yum! Could keep that in all day. Don't mind if I struggle to walk a bit. That's even more fun
05/30/2017
Contributor: Iluvgirth69 Iluvgirth69
I’ve never used a plug I use dildos. My smallest is 2.5. The one I bought yesterday is 3. I’m on the prowl for even more girth. Unfortunately I can’t get the length they’re insanely huge 10 12 and 13 insertable but I love the stretched feeling.
08/23/2018
Contributor: Lisset Finnien Lisset Finnien
I’m wearing the Rear Charmer right now and it is a nice feeling, feels great when walking. (Although I need to charge it so no vibrations I’m expecting the Big Boy today along with the Pearl charming rimming plug. But I’m really looking forward to trying the Big Boy. I like the stretched feeling when playing with a clit toy. Actually, I like that stretched feeling when doing anything. Went to Home Depot ...found that there was one setting on my Rear Charmer that was quiet enough....was a wonderful trip
08/23/2018
Contributor: SoloRebel SoloRebel
1.25” has been my goto size for a while. Kinda getting the curious urge to move up to 1.50”!
10/02/2019