What would you do if you “caught” someone with a butt plug in them?

Contributor: Sera Sera
This depends on who it is, but I'd be turned on with it in me. I get turned on looking at the ryder anal plug, the purple one especially.
07/28/2010
Contributor: Avant-garde Avant-garde
Im male and I would probably get a kick out of it and tell them to enjoy; then walk out.
07/28/2010
Contributor: NymphetamineKiss NymphetamineKiss
I said I'd be turned on. And I'm pretty sure I would. I find anal really, really hot... easily as hot as any other sexual act... so I'd love it really...
08/02/2010
Contributor: Intrigued Intrigued
Quote:
Originally posted by namelesschaos
I recently had my first experience wearing a butt plug out in public and it made me think of the following questions:

1) Let say you just picked someone up and are about to have some fun when you discover the person you just picked up was in ... more
Sounds like foreplay to me. How exciting to find my man has taken it upon himself to wear a plug to pick me up!
08/13/2010
Contributor: heydude heydude
I think I'd be pretty turned on if I caught my date with one.
09/02/2010
Contributor: lamira lamira
I've never seen anyone in public wearing a butt plug - maybe I'm not looking hard enough. But, if I did, I don't think I'd really care. To each his/her own.
10/02/2010
Contributor: Rainbow Boy Rainbow Boy
This is probably going to sound kind of strange, but here it goes:

I'm male, and I'd be turned on if I caught someone, only if he was male and we were intimate. However, if it's a girl we're talking about here, I'd feel a little strange about it. It may seem odd, but I'm only comfortable with doing guys anally and girls vaginally.

Alternately, if I was wearing the plug and I was with a close male companion, I'd leave it in. However, if I was with a close female companion, I'd take the plug out.

Confusing, I know.
10/08/2010
Contributor: Trashley Trashley
I put confused because the only people who I know like to play with anal plugs and extended play are like BROTHERS to me, and it'd just be like.. what.. oh OH OHHHHH MY oh my god i'm sorry dude, here ya go...

But if someone else was picking me up I'd leave that shit in!
10/30/2010
Contributor: Twist Twist
If I caught a female than I would be turned on. I caught some guy id just flash that out of memory and walk away.
11/15/2010
Contributor: DustBunny DustBunny
I'm really interest in discreet public play, so that's an easy and silent way to go about it. I don't think anyone would discover it besides the one it's meant for. I am turned on by the idea, but still don't know where he stands on it.
11/15/2010
Contributor: Kimbertrees Kimbertrees
I'd be really confused probably. Lol.
11/23/2010
Contributor: Lavendar Menace Lavendar Menace
Quote:
Originally posted by carnivalesq
It's all dependent on the person.

I had an LTR and the guy had been wearing a plug for hours, around my family, and I was SQUICKED.

But someone hot, out on a date? Possibly, very turned on.
Wearing one around family does seem...inappropriate.

Unless it was in a situation like that, I'm pretty sure I would be intrigued and turned on.

I would leave the plug in. If the person didn't like it, I'd just say "buh-by."
11/23/2010
Contributor: Ropeguy Ropeguy
I would for sure roll with it. It would be a huge turn on and right then and there.
Never worn one out of the house, but it would be interesting to try sometime.
11/29/2010
Contributor: ToyTimeTim ToyTimeTim
I think I would ask if I could manipulate for them, maybe ask it they would put mine in for me so we could both have pleasure together.
11/29/2010
Contributor: Vexed Vexed
If I saw a butt plug in a woman's ass, I'd be turned on! If I saw one in a guys ass, I'd think positively of his choice and maybe become curious about him, but I wouldn't feel turned on, even though I'm bi. I'm a bottom, and it's all about anal pleasure for me when I'm with men. With women, I like to top or bottom.
01/09/2011
Contributor: Gallowraven Gallowraven
Quote:
Originally posted by namelesschaos
I recently had my first experience wearing a butt plug out in public and it made me think of the following questions:

1) Let say you just picked someone up and are about to have some fun when you discover the person you just picked up was in ... more
Im engaged now, but before I was, I would probably take it out, out of fear that the other person may be into only vanilla sexual encounters, and that they would think me a freak, on the other hand, if I had the opportunity to find out whether they find that sort of thing interesting, Id probably leave it in. but I would be totally turned on catching someone. and after I found out, I would spend the rest of the night teasing it. (the fun kind of teasing)
01/10/2011
Contributor: KnK KnK
I'd be intrigued. It's immature, but I might possibly giggle
01/19/2011
Contributor: mrs.mckrakn mrs.mckrakn
depends
01/19/2011
Contributor: roarr roarr
I am male and if I pick up girl with butt plug in, I'll become sooo... hm... turned on!! But with one in me I think that I will get him out at first chance...
01/25/2011
Contributor: Free Free
Hm. I'd definitely be turned on by it, but a little confused.
01/25/2011
Contributor: FanofSteel FanofSteel
Well damn I'd just have to drop trou and show them my own I guess.
01/31/2011
Contributor: I Wear The Pants I Wear The Pants
I think I would be really confused and do the nervous giggling thing.
01/31/2011
Contributor: kawigrl kawigrl
I'd probably find a way to excuse myself and walk away
01/31/2011
Contributor: Herper Herper
Hey, I don't think I would mind.
02/10/2011
Contributor: TheSinDoll TheSinDoll
I will say that if I was told to leave the plug in, then I'd leave it in. If I had it in because I wanted to wear it, then it would depend on the person I was picking up as to whether or not I left it in or took it out.
02/12/2011
Contributor: Eliza Eliza
I've never used one, but I would be neutral if I caught someone else (surprised, but neutral--maybe a little more turned on), but I would take it out if someone was about to catch me.
02/12/2011
Contributor: guy4guyz420 guy4guyz420
i dont know what id do
02/23/2011
Contributor: Mr.RightNow Mr.RightNow
could be a nice surprise
02/28/2011
Contributor: Mr.RightNow Mr.RightNow
Quote:
Originally posted by SilkyJohnson
ofcourse it would depend who it was
true
03/09/2011
Contributor: Skitlz Skitlz
I use them in public, and I think it would be difficult to get caugt if you are being smart about it.
03/10/2011