I voted 'Compatible', but I find that an inaccurate answer...
See, my boyfriend is a dead sexy guy who works out regularly and leads an active life - he's not a body builder or anything, just with really, really, REALLY nice curves in all the right places.  It's something I absolutely adore about him because I am a very touch-oriented person and love to just explore his body with my hands, lips and tongue.  I don't get tired of it.
Myself on the other hand, to put it in a not-so-kind-light (because I hate softening words,) am a fat bastard.  Certainly I have a lot more muscle on me than most might expect, but at the end of the day I still weigh far too much and really do -not- like my body.  I am struggling to deal with my weight, but it is slow going.  I don't actually like being touched and fondled because I don't like how I look...
BUT, my boyfriend there is a bit of a chubby-chaser, so he rather likes me being this big though he fully supports me trying to get healthy, even if it will be a small blow to his preference.
As it stands, as we are now we each see eachother as extremely attractive, even if I do not actually see myself as such.  Certainly we are both getting what we want out of physical attraction, but it is a bit hard on him because I am unable to get completely comfortable with his fascination of my size, since I hate being this way.
Yes!  Confusion, ho!