EdenFantasys t-shirt - gags by EdenFantasys - review by geliebt

EdenFantasys t-shirt: Cute, comfortable, but a little too short.

This is a great shirt. It seems sturdy, the sleeves are long enough to cover the upper arms, and the sizing is alright.
NO cap sleeves!
Looks great
Good quality
Difference in fabric between first and second order?
A little too short
Rating by reviewer:
extremely useful review
I have two of these, and both are great. I got them both in a medium and they both fit about the same. I wear a 38C bra, have a 33“ waist and 39“ hip. I feel like they would easily fit someone smaller than me, but I probably wouldn’t push it more than an inch or so larger for the medium, or it could fit more tightly than it’s supposed to. My biggest issue is that the length is a little lacking. I’ll probably modify the smaller one to fit longer.

On both shirts I have, the stitching is solid and just like other T-shirts I’ve had for years. I think these will hold up really well! They have seams along the sides of the shirt, and on the underside of the sleeves, instead of circular knit T-shirts without these seams.

I must note that my favorite aspect of these shirts it the sleeves are long enough to cover the upper arms! I am not a fan of cap sleeves, and like to be able to keep my biceps hidden if at all possible, since I’m pretty self-conscious about them. I was a little worried these might end up having super short sleeves, as many shirts do, but that is not the case! I was very pleasantly surprised by this. Really, I can’t get over how happy I am with the sleeves!

The big weird thing was the difference between the two shirts. I ordered one on September 16th, 2011. This one is super stretchy and slinky, and the fabric seems thinner than many other shirts. The neckline comes up quite high, and the length of the shirt is good, if a tiny bit short for my tastes. The second one (also in a size medium) was ordered on October 25th, 2011. This one was also a little bit stretchier than many other T-shirts, but not nearly as much as the first Edenfantasys t-shirt. The fit is about the same, but it fits shorter than the other. It’s short enough that it will expose my belly if I raise my arms at all. Both have a tiny tag in the back of the neck denoting the size, and nothing more.

The design on both shirts looks great. The first, slinkier one has a more solid print than the second one, however. The one from October has a few little gaps in the print, and it looks like the ink isn’t as opaque as the other. This is not really noticeable unless you inspect the design, but it’s definitely apparent if you look.

There’s not tons to say about this shirt. I feel like the sizing is fairly accurate. Normally, I order shirts bigger than I think I’ll need, because they tend to run small. My only issue here with the sizing was the length, which is something I encounter with most shirts. The quality is awesome, especially for something offered as a free gift, and I think despite the small shortcomings in the design on one of mine, these are all around great shirts.
Follow-up commentary
I'm still fond of these shirts, but the sizing is definitely weeeeird!

I ordered a 2X just recently. It seems to be a very soft, yet not super stretchy cotton. The length seems right for a 2X (it lands midway over my butt, but this fits me pretty comfortably. It's loose, but not super baggy as I expected it to be. As someone who normally wears a Medium or Large t-shirt, I can say with confidence that this is DEFINITELY too small for a 2X!
The print on it looks nice. It's pretty stiff and doesn't seem like it would hold up to really being stretched, though. But it is pretty vibrant save for just a few spots where the black comes through just a touch.
I still like these shirts, but the sizing is crazy- when you order your first one, I recommend ordering way up if possible just to gauge how you feel about the fit!
This content is the opinion of the submitting contributor and is not endorsed by EdenFantasys.com
Become a Reviewer. Get free toys. Enjoy Special Deals
This review was edited by
  • Antipova Antipova
  • Rank:
  • Edited reviews: 276
  • Graduated students: 22
  • geliebt
    They're fun, even if the sizing is totally wonk! Hope you like it!!
  • samanthalynn
    Good review
  • PassionCpl
    Thanks for the review. We just got one as a Freebie and love the material but it's large and only just fits me (hubby) who's usually a large and is tight on my big-boobed wife (who's usually a medium). Still, great for the price - i.e. shipping!
  • geliebt
    Glad you like yours! I wish it was easier to figure the sizing out, but at least there's a lot that can be done with a Tshirt, anyway
  • richsam
    thanks for the review
  • geliebt
    You're quite welcome!
Discussion Posts Last Update
Eden hoodies and tank tops? 44
Material? 12
different t-shirt material 4
EdenFantasys T-Shirt 69
#AskEden - Sizing and quality of the EF shirt? 3
#AskEden - EF Shirt Sizes 4
Eden's T-shirt 45
Thank you for viewing EdenFantasys t-shirt – gags review page!