The New Intimacy
  • Free Shipping With Orders $55+
  • EXTRA 15% OFF ANY ORDER — USE: WOW15
  • SPRING SALE : SAVE UP TO 85%

The Definitive Doughnut Smackdown

Forum search
Contributor: sixfootsex sixfootsex 04/17/2011

For those of you who are passionate about doughnuts (or donuts, for the anti-silent-consonant crowd), this comparative discussion will establish, once and for all, which are the best types of doughnuts and (hopefully) why. Feel free to argue fervently amongst yourselves about your feelings for these peerless pastries.

Invited: All users.

Discussion Topics

1.
Filled vs. Unfilled (97 posts)
2.
Cake vs. Yeast (35 posts)
3.
Best Fillings (50 posts)
4.
Best Toppings (32 posts)
5.
Best of the Doughnut's Distant Relations (48 posts)
6.
Best Place to Buy? (74 posts)
Contributor: sixfootsex sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
Answers (public voting - your screen name will appear in the results):
sixfootsex , barrettbn2 , Lio , nicole07 , PiratePrincess , Ansley , Yoda , Ashley:) , A Closet Slut (aka nipplepeople) , sexy19364 , Joie de Cherresse , Lady Marmelade , MaryExy , Linga , Mseg20 , Bunnycups , Lumberman , mb , *Huxley* , Lolla Munz , Miss T , Rossie , darthkitt3n , Jobthingy , cobiffle , littlezimmey , alliegator , Cream in the Cupcake , Mr. E , The Curious Couple , Ajax , Ratito , Kaltir , lolsos , Vaccinium , nonchalant01 , EndlessFrost , Smitty , Dizzykakes , REDRUM , potstickers , sarki , DCorrelle , Shellz31 , Jackol , MJ1337 , melissa1973 , CAKES , BeautifulDarkness , Endocott , Ghost , ily , PussyPurr , mizzmilla , LuciFaery , Ash1141 , PunkyB , unfulfilled , ToyBoy , JessCee , -BillD , padmeamidala , aimtoplease , Love Perpetua , shcoo , wrmbreze , karay123 , switzerland , HannahPanda , EdenJP , Megan Jean , Apirka , Rin (aka Nire) , Modern^Spank^Anthem , Katelyn , BlooJay , fufucat , Curiouscat , booboo111926 , Kitka , ghalik , Nirelan , AshMegYo , jennifur77 , Deeder , LoveYouLikeThat , LovesAPoet , hot lil momma , digit88 , cryinglightning86 , FHeemz , J5ive , brevado , TheGreat , Tangles , Mrs.Intensity , rosythorn , puglove , hhh , Cat E. , Aftertherain13 , no longer here , Lildrummrgurl7 , invisiblehat
104  (35%)
firekitten , ToyTimeTim , BBW Talks Toys , DeliciousSurprise , bluekaren , leela , married with children , Annemarie , Midway through , Reny , wetone123 , Fernand0 , slynch , El-Jaro , *Ashley* , dv8 , link82 , Airen Wolf , Crystal1 , Dusk , Judas Iscars , lesbianlesbian , starsNairguitars , pinkcupcakes , zracer , C4ss , kelaaa33wish , Selective Sensualist , leatherlover , Unconventional , Diabolical Kitty , teeny <3 , AOutrajus , Kim! , yoham45 , Dyma , Virgulino , Wondermom , Teaser , sassyNsensual , Mary-Anne-Xun , GravyCakes , Marble , Reyes , jay28 , Acorn , UunicornN , MirelleDion , Steve of Eden , boobookittyfuk , mistressg , ThoughtsAblaze , EJ , Pink Jewel , Beck , Breas , Bignuf , IslandGoddess , kellyg , Jon S , Paladin Fantasys , TheSlyFox , Jammin14580 , jacki , Eliza , GenderSexplorations , PeachieClean , geliebt , WhoopieDoo , solita , Anjulie , Darklyvan , GONE! , biancajames , Missmarc , null , markwashere , eeep , FemmeFlo , KyotoAngel , Entropy , chantal coopette , chantalgiardina , MissCandyland , HugsAndBites , Zombirella , Incendiaire , PeaceToTheMiddleEast , jmex83 , wdanas , xOhxSoxScandalousx , Hallmar82 , LavenderSkies , Llahsram , little miss kinky , pirata , mmmmm , s3 , redstars , ksparkles16 , PropertyOfPotter , ViVix , indiechick , Owl , hyacinthgirl , Princess Zelda , T&L , damnbul12 , ginnyluvspotter , natashaanime , Alyxx , sugar&spikes , SaraW0512 , Rod Ronald , MrsHouseWife , Xarien , travelnurse , TheirPet , FunFantasys , lainebug , spiced , Living Doll
122  (41%)
James Toyman , bunny love , Carmb47 , namelesschaos , Taboada , Kindred , chidoll , Jul!a , Lithaewyn , tickle me pink , KnK , KrystalFayeO , Howells , Andromeda , ZenaidaMacroura , 0 , cujo467 , Lily Night , M121212 , Coralbell , sasweetheart89 , k3 , toxie m , liilii080 , CuteDee , MeliPixie , meganthomas , lovemuscle n cookie , C-Rae , SiNn , onehotmomma , RonLee , TameTemptress , cheetahpita , Lucky21 , Ryuson , dhig , carenautilus , domsub1993 , Vanille , mpfm , Adriana Ravenlust , Chul , Peggi , OroNomi , SweetSurprise , voenne , LaSchwartz , loveshocks , Greenleaf , MamaDivine , Undead , DreamWolf , Stinkytofu10 , duff , Nazaress , RiahPapaya , pootpootpoot , sexxxkitten , Falsepast , MistressDandelion , Lilith Bealove , Claire-Bear , lulz , Dixiemomma , glasskitten , AliMc , Mamastoys , neil i. , Lavendar
70  (24%)
Total votes: 296
Poll is open
04/17/2011
  • Long-distance pleasure set for couples
  • Anal Sub Hook&Rope Kit for $19.99 Only
  • Complete strap-on set for extra 15% off
  • Save Extra 30% On The Bigger the Better Kit
  • E-stim attachment and controller set
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
All promotions
Contributor: barrettbn2 barrettbn2
Unfilled! Now you have me craving donuts! Gee thanks lol
04/17/2011
Contributor: nicole07 nicole07
I hate creme fillings!
04/17/2011
Contributor: firekitten firekitten
I loooooove fruit or custard filled ones. Not the cream though, that's too sweet.
04/17/2011
Contributor: PiratePrincess PiratePrincess
Unfilled. I'm not a fan of cream or anything inside.
04/17/2011
Contributor: Yoda Yoda
We make our doughnuts with holes in them. Then we sell the middle bits separately as one-bite doughnuts, or, "Timbits". That's the Canadian way.
04/17/2011
Contributor: sixfootsex sixfootsex
Quote:
Originally posted by Yoda
We make our doughnuts with holes in them. Then we sell the middle bits separately as one-bite doughnuts, or, "Timbits". That's the Canadian way.
Timbits? I love that. Obviosuly I should take a jaunt to Canada... ya know... in the interests of research.
04/17/2011
Contributor: married with children married with children
lemon filled is the best
04/18/2011
Contributor: Linga Linga
Plain old glazed krispy kremes are my fave!
04/18/2011
Contributor: Annemarie Annemarie
Filled. I'm a fan of Eclairs.
04/18/2011
Contributor: Bunnycups Bunnycups
The only filled donut I like is Boston creme.
04/18/2011
Contributor: namelesschaos namelesschaos
I picked don't make me chose, also curse you for making me this hungry.
04/18/2011
Contributor: *Huxley* *Huxley*
Unfilled yeast doughnuts win every time. Or those pumpkin cake doughnuts that come out around fall. YUM.
04/18/2011
Contributor: Lithaewyn Lithaewyn
It totally depends! Some flavor combinations just won't work together and others are great.
04/18/2011
Contributor: link82 link82
cream filled - no custard or jelly!!!
04/18/2011
Contributor: KnK KnK
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
All of them O_O Mine nom nom nom
04/19/2011
Contributor: KrystalFayeO KrystalFayeO
I only like the cream filled donuts from krispy kreme, all other filled donut fillings are gross!
04/19/2011
Contributor: KrystalFayeO KrystalFayeO
Quote:
Originally posted by Yoda
We make our doughnuts with holes in them. Then we sell the middle bits separately as one-bite doughnuts, or, "Timbits". That's the Canadian way.
we have those in America, they're called doughnut holes!
04/19/2011
Contributor: Jobthingy Jobthingy
Quote:
Originally posted by Yoda
We make our doughnuts with holes in them. Then we sell the middle bits separately as one-bite doughnuts, or, "Timbits". That's the Canadian way.
*nods* but they also have filled ones. I just dont like them. Blech
04/19/2011
Contributor: Andromeda Andromeda
Both!!!!!!!!!! But especially filled... but still both
04/19/2011
Contributor: cobiffle cobiffle
just a good fresh chocolate donut is the best
04/19/2011
Contributor: Selective Sensualist Selective Sensualist
I like both. For filled doughnuts, I like more of a custard-type filling than a jelly or whipped filling because the jelly and whipped fillings are too sweet for my taste.

When I want something that is unfilled, I absolutely LOVE a fresh maple-frosted doughnut. Though I love chocolate, I am extremely picky about chocolate frosting on doughnuts. Most doughnut places have a terrible chocolate frosting that they use on their doughnuts, so when I find a place that uses a good chocolate frosting, I appreciate them that much more. I also love strawberry frosting as long is it is not overly sweet as some strawberry frosting can be.

Oh, and powdered sugar doughnut holes are also fantastic!

The very, very, VERY best doughnuts I've ever had were at Round Rock Donuts, which is located outside of Austin, Texas. They are hand-rolled, homemade yeast doughnuts that have a unique appearance when you bite into them: the dough is naturally a light orange! If you ever visit Austin, I suggest you make a trip to Round Rock, a little suburb that is very close by, and get you some of the world's best glazed and chocolate-frosted doughnuts, preferably while they are still hot. Their doughnuts are incredible and unforgettable.
04/27/2011
Contributor: Vaccinium Vaccinium
Give me a simple glazed cruller, and I'll be your friend for life.
04/29/2011
Contributor: Diabolical Kitty Diabolical Kitty
I loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee eeee filled ones!!
04/29/2011
Contributor: nonchalant01 nonchalant01
Quote:
Originally posted by Linga
Plain old glazed krispy kremes are my fave!
you know it.....
04/29/2011
Contributor: Wondermom Wondermom
plain hot glazed krispy kreme and dunkin donuts vanilla creme.

our krispy kreme closed
05/09/2011
Contributor: Dizzykakes Dizzykakes
Quote:
Originally posted by Wondermom
plain hot glazed krispy kreme and dunkin donuts vanilla creme.

our krispy kreme closed
I completely agree with you on that one. I love them fresh and hot.
05/11/2011
Contributor: REDRUM REDRUM
Unfilled.
Glazed is my favorite, but I will occasionally get one with icing and sprinkles on it.
05/11/2011
Contributor: sassyNsensual sassyNsensual
filled!!! I need to get a donut tomorrow lol
05/11/2011
Contributor: Mary-Anne-Xun Mary-Anne-Xun
Filled!
05/11/2011
Contributor: GravyCakes GravyCakes
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
i love cream filled doughnuts. but i don't like jelly filled.
05/11/2011
Contributor: CuteDee CuteDee
OMG! Donuts are sooo good! And there are so many to choose from!!! I love them all!!
05/17/2011
Contributor: MeliPixie MeliPixie
Oh no! Please don't make me choose...!!! A pastry chef's worst nightmare is picking one of her many creations...!!! TT_TT
05/17/2011
Contributor: onehotmomma onehotmomma
I can't decide!
07/05/2011
Contributor: Acorn Acorn
Filled! Jelly filled, powdered donuts are amazing!
07/05/2011
Contributor: CAKES CAKES
I love chocolate covered, custard filled Krispy Kreme doughnuts. I voted unfilled though, cause their hot glazed are so freaking awesome!
07/05/2011
Contributor: boobookittyfuk boobookittyfuk
Bovarian creme filled or icing filled. Yumm... Now i have to go to the store!
07/08/2011
Contributor: Beck Beck
Filled whether it be jelly, cream, pudding, or whatever else is in there. OMG it is awesome!!!! Yum DOUGHNUTS!
08/22/2011
Contributor: Bignuf Bignuf
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
DARN IT...see what you have done. SERIOUS disagreement in our happy home (. HE....KRISPY KREME Chocolate CUSTARD FILLED are the BEST!!!! SHE...oh no, plain GLAZED Krispy Kreme, when the HOT doughnut sign is ON.
08/22/2011
Contributor: LuciFaery LuciFaery
I don't like overly sweet things, and filled doughnuts happen to fall in that category for me, so unfilled all the way!
08/26/2011
Contributor: Rossie Rossie
Quote:
Originally posted by Vaccinium
Give me a simple glazed cruller, and I'll be your friend for life.
Yesssss!!!!! Crullers are the best! Haven't had a good cruller for a while, where do you get yours?
08/27/2011
Contributor: Ash1141 Ash1141
Unfilled! Apple fritters and glazed cake donuts are yummy!! I despise jelly filled!
09/14/2011
Contributor: PunkyB PunkyB
absolutely unfilled
09/14/2011
Contributor: Pink Jewel Pink Jewel
filled with chocolate icing on top
09/15/2011
Contributor: Lucky21 Lucky21
Oh please don't make be choose.
09/25/2011
Contributor: Ryuson Ryuson
(Review Program Mentor)
Only filled if it's with custard!
09/28/2011
Contributor: Love Perpetua Love Perpetua
Prefer then unfilled.
12/07/2011
Contributor: GenderSexplorations GenderSexplorations
Filled with yummy sweet things. Or unfilled. I'm not that picky.
12/10/2011
Contributor: PeachieClean PeachieClean
Filled are the best! The mini-explosion when you bite into them is amazing.
12/10/2011
Contributor: wrmbreze wrmbreze
I prefer unfilled.
12/10/2011
Contributor: biancajames biancajames
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
cream or berry jam filled...mmmm
01/02/2012
Contributor: null null
Cream filled...I might have to go get donuts later...
01/13/2012
Contributor: LaSchwartz LaSchwartz
depends on the filling.
01/15/2012
Contributor: Modern^Spank^Anthem Modern^Spank^Anthem
i love them all
01/15/2012
Contributor: EdenJP EdenJP
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
Filled
01/15/2012
Contributor: Greenleaf Greenleaf
Equal opportunity donut love!
01/16/2012
Contributor: MamaDivine MamaDivine
Omg, I couldn't possibly choose lol.

"Long Johns" filled with bovarian creme
Raspberry filled with powdered sugar
Apple Fritters
etc etc, Ok I need to stop this craziness, its 230am and im craving donuts now! Shame on you LOL
01/16/2012
Contributor: Undead Undead
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
Doesn't matter to me, like them either way.
01/16/2012
Contributor: KyotoAngel KyotoAngel
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
I usually take one big bite and then lick out all the filling...I do that more with Boston Cream doughnuts than jelly ones, the color of the jelly makes it feel more like some nefarious doughnut murder. x'D
01/16/2012
Contributor: Entropy Entropy
I am a man who loves his apple fritters, but I'll take an eclair as top pick every time.
01/16/2012
Contributor: MissCandyland MissCandyland
Filled!!!
02/20/2012
Contributor: duff duff
love em both
02/20/2012
Contributor: HugsAndBites HugsAndBites
two words
boston cream
02/20/2012
Contributor: Zombirella Zombirella
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
Filled but I love both ways
02/20/2012
Contributor: BlooJay BlooJay
Unfilled
02/20/2012
Contributor: Incendiaire Incendiaire
I'm all about a doughnut with a generous filling of raspberry jam.
02/27/2012
Contributor: xOhxSoxScandalousx xOhxSoxScandalousx
Filled. Mmmm now I want donuts dammit!
06/07/2012
Contributor: Ukulele Guy Ukulele Guy
I don't always have doughnuts. But when I do, I prefer them unfilled. Stay hungry, my friends.
06/07/2012
Contributor: 31 Flavors 31 Flavors
Filled with custard, covered in chocolate.
06/07/2012
Contributor: Llahsram Llahsram
Mmmmmm raspberry filling.
06/07/2012
Contributor: Nirelan Nirelan
filled is yucky
06/07/2012
Contributor: sexxxkitten sexxxkitten
I love both!
06/07/2012
Contributor: jennifur77 jennifur77
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
Nothing beats a Krispy Kreme Hot glazed. However, there is a cotton candy flavored one a local gas station sells that is really good.
06/07/2012
Contributor: Deeder Deeder
Unfilled. If there's no hole then it isn't really a donut.
06/08/2012
Contributor: Lilith Bealove Lilith Bealove
Creme filling, depending on my mood
06/10/2012
Contributor: s3 s3
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
I cant make eye contact with anyone at a donut place because I like licking the filling out.
06/24/2012
Contributor: digit88 digit88
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
Unfilled
06/24/2012
Contributor: Claire-Bear Claire-Bear
I like all kinds, but I prefer the cake variety most.
06/24/2012
Contributor: ViVix ViVix
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
Custard filled!
06/25/2012
Contributor: lulz lulz
French curlers are the best
06/25/2012
Contributor: TheGreat TheGreat
Absolutely unfilled!
07/08/2012
Contributor: Mrs.Intensity Mrs.Intensity
unfilled please... gee it's been awhile since a doughnut!
07/08/2012
Contributor: icelandia icelandia
Love it all
09/13/2012
Contributor: T&L T&L
Umm, yes please!!
09/22/2012
Contributor: damnbul12 damnbul12
Filled!
09/22/2012
Contributor: rosythorn rosythorn
When I was little I liked filled up now just unfilled please.
10/19/2012
Contributor: Rod Ronald Rod Ronald
Love em all!
10/28/2012
Contributor: Mamastoys Mamastoys
I like them anyway I can get them but usually have to avoid them!! I'm on a 10 day liquid diet right now to kick in my metabolism and I knew I shouldn't have clicked on this topic!!!!!!
10/28/2012
Contributor: Cat E. Cat E.
I like unfilled.
10/29/2012
Contributor: Xarien Xarien
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
Filled! But my true love is raspberry filled.
10/29/2012
Contributor: Lavendar Lavendar
I love both, depends on my mood really
10/29/2012
Contributor: travelnurse travelnurse
I love all kinds of Doughnuts!
10/29/2012
Contributor: TheirPet TheirPet
Quote:
Originally posted by barrettbn2
Unfilled! Now you have me craving donuts! Gee thanks lol
Me too!
10/29/2012
Contributor: Undecided Undecided
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
Buttercream filled or glazed dipped in cool whip
10/29/2012
Contributor: invisiblehat invisiblehat
Unfilled! Doughnuts without doughnut holes are not proper doughnuts.
01/01/2013
Contributor: lainebug lainebug
Quote:
Originally posted by sixfootsex
Do you like the mystery of the seductive hole? Or do you like licking out the cream?
Like both my fav is bismark cream filled
01/01/2013
Contributor: Living Doll Living Doll
Cream-filled donuts are my favorite (as long as the cream doesn't have a nasty consistency).
01/02/2013