What's too big for a plug?

Perceptive forum discussions on Butt plugs:

Lotion or Body Butter?
Maybe it's because my friends and I are silly, but we actually had a friendly (but heated) debate over the merits of lotion or body butter tonight. I.

Pure Plug Medium vs Metal Worx Luv Plug
Which is the better plug they are both about the same size 1 1/4 in diameter, but the Luv Plug is 1 longer and 1 longer in insertable length, I know..

Anal play: vibe or butt plug?
just curious out there as to what people out there use for their anal play. ive used vibrating dildos for all of mine and loved it. anyone else care..

How can I convince my boyfriend to use butt plugs?
My boyfriend is interested and has participated in some anal play before. We used fingers once and he's taken an old traditional vibrator a few times.

Rear ender – butt plug
I just got this today and it is HUGE. Is it just me, or am I the only one who cant find a just right size for me? I ordered one that was TINY and this

Totally depends on the person and what you'll be doing with it. For me, I like the big, wide ones but others may like something different. For whatever reason, I prefer large anal toys. The small ones aren't any fun for me. BIG BIG BIG!!!

Anything over 1 1/2" in dia.

2 1/2 is too big for me... for now that is.

I really like silicone 1 1/4 " plugs they fit me really nice and give me the stimulation I like sometimes I go to 1 1/2 " plugs for a more filling feeling. Plus I can get 2 silicone plugs for less than half of the steel plugs, for me it's a no brainer 2 for 1/2 the price of steel

For now, the Ryder is plenty big for me.

Any size that causes discomfort to put in - I'm happy with my Njoy Pure plug medium with a diameter 1.25".