Informative topic breakdown of Butt plugs:

Whats the biggest butt plug/anal toy on the site?
I'm looking for something that will scare people haha. Something witha wow factor, the perfect gift.

I don't have a grab it or an assignment button anymore, How do I write reviews now?
I was just recently upgraded to an advanced reviewer now I don't have a grab it or an assignment button anymore, so How do I write reviews now? Please

Do you use anal plugs?
I guess this is simple.

Fun Factory and Butt Plugs
First of all, I am really excited that you joined Edenfantasys. I am a huge fan of your fun and colorful products, and I've gotta catch 'em all! So...

What's too big for a plug?
what do you think is too big for a butt plug?

I would recommend for you the NJoy Pure Plug Medium. link
(Or the large for larger framed or more experienced folks).

-Well worth the price. The small tends to fall out.

I don't suggest the Pure Plugs straight off. They're metal, and, while very comfortable, they are very unforgiving.

The Bootie is well liked around here, though I don't own it. Joe Rock is also a good choice.

Basically, you're looking for about the 1.25" in diameter range. You could go up to 1.5" in diameter, but no larger than that, as a beginner. Warm up a lot if you go above 1.25" in diameter.

Stick with silicone--it's soft, forgiving, and generally comfortable.

I been dying for the pure plug medium for a while, it's out stock

I'd probably go with the Fun Factory Bootie (a nice sized silicone plug), or the Pure Plug Medium (quite expensive, but made of stainless steel and will last you forever).